New Ecuadorean tree species named after Attenborough


This video is about parrots at clay licks in Ecuador.

From the World Land Trust:

Spectacular New Species of Tree Named in Honour of Sir David Attenborough

June 2009 – Blakea attenboroughii is now the official scientific name of a spectacular new species of tree found only in Ecuador. This beautiful tree, with magnificent bright blue flowers, has now been formally described and published in the Proceedings of the Californian Academy of Science, and named in honour of the great natural historian and World Land Trust patron, Sir David Attenborough.

In November 2007 Lou Jost, an American Botanist who works with the World Land Trust’s Ecuadorian project partners, Fundación EcoMinga, was taking a WLT staff member and also a representative from WLT’s company sponsors, Puro Coffee, to visit the newly created nature reserve at Cerro Candelaria in Ecuador, when they found what they thought might be a species of tree new to science.

Lou’s suspicions proved correct and the tree has now features in the Proceedings of the California Academy of Science, under the name of Blakea attenboroughii. It was felt appropriate to name the tree in honour of Sir David Attenborough who has supported the World Land Trust since its foundation and has been its patron since 2004 when he launched a campaign to raise funds for the purchase of a rainforest reserve in Ecuador.

This is no ordinary tree — it is, so far, only known to occur in a tiny area of Ecuador (though further research may find it further a field) — and it has spectacular bright blue flowers. The reserve areas purchased by local Ecuadorian conservation groups, with funding from the World Land Trust, are proving to be a real treasure trove of biodiversity with many new species of orchid being discovered — some of which are being named after sponsors of the land purchase — as well as new species of frog and other wildlife.

Punk poet Seething Wells dies


This video from Britain says about itself:

Seething Wells – Agro Britain [about Rupert Murdoch‘s Sun newspaper]

Taken from the EP ‘Rough, raw & ranting’ by Seething Wells & Attila the Stockbroker, Radical Wallpaper, England, 1982.

By British ex-miner and 1984-85 striker, Norman Strike [not a pseudonym]:

Tuesday 30 June 2009

Obituary
Steven Wells 1960 -2009

A great man died in the US last week. The things he said and wrote entertained, amused and angered a lot of people.

This man was a real revolutionary socialist, poet, wit, class warrior and a great writer, and his death has left a huge gap in countless peoples’ lives.

Steven Wells (aka Seething Wells aka Susan Williams aka Swells) was born in Swindon in 1960 – and I wish I’d known that so I could have called him a “soft southern shite” like I’d heard him call so many others born south of Yorkshire!

Swells first came to my attention as a so-called “ranting poet”, alongside others such as Attila the Stockbroker, Joolz and Porky the Poet. I saw him supporting some of my favourite bands – the Fall and the Mekons.

I really liked his poem, Tetley Bittermen, which I think I’d heard on John Peel’s radio show, so I was pleased when I got to know him during, and especially after, the Miners’ Strike of 1984-5.

We even shared a house for a brief period and attended Socialist Workers Party meetings in Willesden, though we both struggled with party discipline.

He was also a stalwart of the Anti Nazi League and had the arrowed logo tattooed on his arm.

An old friend of his from those days, Paul Sillett, recalls a Redskins gig in Brixton where they were collecting for the miners and Swells viciously verbally attacked a famous Radio One DJ for giving nothing and almost had him in tears.

He added, “Funnier still that at the same gig, try as he might, Swells collected hardly a penny for the miners as everyone gave generously to every bucket that was proffered apart from Swells own one.

‘Fer Chrissakes,’ he yelled, ‘Why am I the only bugger that can’t get money for the miners?!’”

Swells took no prisoners in either his poetry or his journalism and wrote many memorable articles in the music paper NME during the 1980s.

As his long time friend and ex-Redskins bassist, Martin Bottomley, said, “He was one of the most intolerant people you could ever meet – he hated racists, sexists, homophobes and Tories, and as a journalist he continued to persecute these people with all his wit!”

Swells, in recent years, wrote a brilliant sports column for the Guardian. …

I loved Swells’ writing but reading the three articles about his battle with cancer finally made me realise just what a great writer he was.

His death made me cry hot salty tears, and reading those articles just added to the flow.

“And suddenly it hits me. I’m poleaxed, sobbing uncontrollably. I feel very vulnerable and very, very scared.

“This is followed by 24 tedious hours of horribly gothic adolescent introspection during which almost every line of thought concludes with, ‘But what’s the point if you’re going to die anyway?’”

Who’d have thought that post traumatic shock would have so much in common with being a Radiohead fan?

Ah Swells, so bloody talented, vitriolic, scathing. I am really going to miss you but console myself with the fact that your writing will live forever.

And how bloody apt that your very last written words were: “Me? I blame it on sunshine. I blame it on the moonlight. I blame it on the boogie.”

Michael Jackson grabs all the headlines but Steven Wells grabs your soul! RIP Swells.

See also here. And here.

Afro-punk: here.

Italian anti-Mussolini fighter interviewed


This video is an Italian interview with Luigi Fiori.

From British weekly Socialist Worker:

The ‘Devil’ who helped drive Nazis out of Italy

Italian partisan Luigi Fiori spoke to Tom Behan about his role in resisting fascism in Italy

For somebody who was born just after the First World War, Luigi Fiori is an amazingly busy person.

When I phoned his landline he was on his mobile making the final arrangements to speak at an anti-fascist meeting.

Luigi, a former Italian partisan who resisted both Benito Mussolini’s fascist regime and German Nazis, is coming to the Marxism festival in central London this week to speak on the fight against fascism, then and now.

He is a worried man, concerned about the votes for the fascists in the European elections and the presence of fascists within the Italian government.

Members of Silvio Berlusconi’s right wing government have their political roots in the fascist period.

As Luigi says, “They just pretend to be democrats. Take Gianfranco Fini, the speaker of the parliament and the former leader of the National Alliance party.

“He’s been to the Wailing Wall in Israel and paid homage to the victims of Italy’s racial laws.

“He’s a fascist but he’s not stupid. He’s not a rabid dog. His ilk are just waiting for the right moment.

“Once Berlusconi falls – and he’s wobbling a bit at the moment – Fini and his gang will make a bid for power.”

Fiori is also worried because he experienced fascism as a schoolboy.

Mussolini’s National Fascist Party took power in Italy in 1922 and imposed a one party state that ruled with an iron fist.

Luigi said, “We knew nothing about what was happening outside of Italy. We were totally isolated.

Repression

“Society was totalitarian and you couldn’t speak a word out of turn.

“When other people of my age say, ‘I used to say’ I respond with comments like, ‘What do you mean? You couldn’t say anything.’

“Fascism was normality. Due to the level of repression, the anti-fascists – we didn’t know who they were – didn’t dare talk to us because we were just kids.

“They would have risked too much by revealing their identities to us.”

Even the taking of exams was an excuse for indoctrination.

If you weren’t wearing the fascist uniform then you weren’t allowed to take your place in the examination hall.

Soon after leaving school Fiori was called up to serve in the Italian army in the Second World War.

When the fascist regime collapsed in 1943, Luigi – along with tens of thousands of others – refused to serve in the puppet army set up by the Nazis and a severely weakened Mussolini.

Luigi and his comrades went up into the mountains to become partisans – armed anti-fascist resistance fighters.

Guerilla

Over the next 18 months they fought – and won – a bitter guerrilla war against fascists and German Nazis.

As opposed to a conventional army, the resistance movement had no hierarchy of ranks.

Commanders were elected and their powers could be immediately revoked.

Fiori led a unit in the Appenine mountains.

For security reasons he was only known by a codeword: “Commander Friar Devil”.

He never tires of telling young people that his generation faced terrible problems – and overcame them.

“When I speak at meetings I’m always saying to people: ‘Look kids, don’t give up.’

“Many are the times the Nazis assembled between 10,000 and 12,000 men to attack us, and they really knocked the hell out of us.

“But ten days later we were back on our feet again, and had already organised another brigade.”

Fiori is keen to learn about the situation in Britain, and agrees that parties such as the fascist British National Party (BNP) need to be confronted on the streets.

He says, “We need to be careful though as normally they have the police on their side.

“However, we’re far stronger denouncing what they’re doing – shouting loud and clear that what they’re doing is dangerous.

“We’ve been far too tolerant for far too long – these people shouldn’t be allowed to go around waving swastikas.

“Our strength lies in our commitment and our numbers.”

Only days before the G8 summit opens, a new security law directed primarily against illegal immigrants comes into force in Italy: here.

Ulster nazis threaten Asian-Irish politician


Anna Lo

From British daily The Morning Star:

Belfast extremists threaten politician

Tuesday 30 June 2009

by Tom Mellen

Right-wing extremists in Belfast have threatened to attack the home of the Stormont Assembly’s only minority community representative.

Alliance Party MLA Anna Lo, (pictured) who is originally from Hong Kong, told fellow assembly members on Monday that police have warned her of a threat to attack her home.

Ms Lo, who has lived in Belfast for nearly 35 years, said she had also received hate mail after speaking out against the attacks that forced 20 Romanian families to flee their south Belfast homes earlier this month.

Ms Lo reported that threatening letters have recently been sent to Polish and Islamic centres in Belfast by loyalist far-right groups, with at least one containing a bombing threat.

“People from ethnic minority communities are very frightened,” she observed, adding that she will continue to speak out in support of Belfast’s embattled migrant communities.

Stormont deputies roundly condemned the spate of racist attacks blighting Belfast.

But Ms Lo slammed Assembly Members who condemned racism while suggesting that crime emanated from migrant communities.

“I am saddened really by some of those comments,” she said.

“Of course, there are good apples and bad apples in all communities but that is not the cause for racist attacks. We need to address racism, hate crimes of all types in our society,” she added.

Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness agreed, saying: “What goes to the heart of the whole issue of dealing with this is the need for a recognition that everybody is equal and everybody is entitled to be treated with equality.”

Irish trade unions rally against racism: here.

England: A brutal racist attack on a 17 year old Asian woman in a park in Rochdale last week left her suffering horrific injuries: here.

The persecution of the Roma people continues across Europe with vicious results, writes Eamonn McCann: here.

The Muslim, Polish and Indian communities in Northern Ireland have received new threats from loyalist extremists, just weeks after more than 100 Romanian nationals fled the six counties following a wave of attacks on their homes: here.

Seven Belfast HM Revenue and Customs staff were sacked yesterday for racially abusing non-nationals who received child benefit: here.

Northern Ireland violence drives out immigrant families: here.

Argentine president joins Zelaya in return to Honduras


Cristina Fernández de Kirchner

From the Buenos Aires Herald in Argentina:

CFK to join Zelaya in return to Honduras

President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner will join Honduran President Manuel Zelaya in his return to that country, after a coup overthrew his government on Sunday, an unidentified source in the government told reporters in Buenos Aires.

“The President will be among the delegation of the Association of American States that will travel to Honduras with Zelaya,” said the source. The decision of the Kirchner administration was adopted “to show the clear political will of the region to return the ousted authority to his post,” he added.

Zelaya, a leftist president who is very close to Venezuelan leader Hugo Chávez, was captured by a military operation on Sunday and he was brought to Costa Rica …

The coup in Honduras was condemned by the OAS, the European Union, the UN and the government of the United States, which imports about 80 percent of Honduras’ exports.

It is to be hoped that the Pinochet wannabees of Honduras will give up peacefully; and will not try with violence, like the real Pinochet of Chile and the Argentine dictators did, to stop Zelaya from returning to work in the presidential office.

Laura Carlsen: Honduran Coup Turns Violent, Sanctions Imposed: here.

The US and the Honduran coup: here.

Young Japanese protest on economy


This video is about Japanese protest against the G-8 summit.

From the New York Times in the USA:

Young Japanese Raise Their Voices Over Economy

By HIROKO TABUCHI

Published: June 29, 2009

TOKYO — A group of young people recently gathered in a darkened park here. Holding placards and megaphones, they chanted slogans condemning the Japanese government and a lack of jobs and opportunity.

The scene, which is repeated often in the gritty Tokyo neighborhood of Koenji, is nothing close to the protests that have recently shaken Iran. Indeed, the protests would hardly raise an eyebrow in most parts of the world, but in this country, which values conformity, they represent a stark departure from the norm. Since the 1960s, when youth protests turned violent, even the mildest form of protests by young people has been viewed as taboo.

But the pain of recession is changing that, giving rise to a new activism among Japan’s youth, who have long been considered apathetic.

“I’m here because I want to change society,” one leader, Yoshihiro Sato, 28, recently shouted to a crowd of about 50. “Will you join me?” …

The Tokyo-based Pacific Asia Research Center, an institute that typically runs seminars on social issues like poverty, organized the recent march. After a surge of interest from young people who said they wanted to get more involved in social issues but did not know how, the center started offering what it says is Japan’s first activist training program. The sessions include poster-making and campaigning on the Web.

“Once we’re done, we’ll overrun Japan with demonstrations,” Seiko Uchida, the head of a research center, told a cheering crowd.

That may be hyperbole, but the deteriorating economy has inarguably affected young people more than any other demographic. Unemployment was 9.6 percent in April for Japanese aged 15 to 24, compared with 5 percent unemployment over all.

But unemployment and welfare benefits are sparse in Japan. And government spending is skewed toward pensions and health care for older voters rather than programs that might train young workers or help them support their families.

In the first quarter of the year, Japan’s economy shrank a devastating 14.2 percent on an annual basis, as exports slumped because of the global economic slowdown. Many of those who lost their jobs were younger people in precarious “temporary” positions that were the product of a decade-long deregulation. …

When companies like Canon and Toyota Motor started to fire temporary factory workers late last year, a handful of the workers lashed out publicly, confronting managers at factory gates, often in front of TV cameras. Others brought a flurry of lawsuits against former employers.

Over the New Year’s holidays, about 500 laid-off temporary workers who had lost their homes congregated at a park in the center of Tokyo, building an impromptu tent city next to the offices of the Labor Ministry. The scene led to a media frenzy and national soul-searching on the plight of young Japanese.

Today, workers are rushing to unionize, and the Japanese Communist Party says it is getting about 1,000 new members a month, many of them disgruntled young people.

Masahiro Mukasa, a struggling techno musician, started a union for freelance artists and musicians in December. The Indy Union intends to help members negotiate with particularly abusive employers.

“People think musicians just have a good time. But we need to make a living, too,” Mr. Mukasa said. “I want to show that our livelihoods are at stake in this bad economy.” …

Still, “this is the most significant rise in activism I’ve seen in years,” said Yoshitaka Mouri, a professor at the Tokyo University of the Arts, who has been following the rising protest culture. “A movement is brewing among young Japanese.”

Hajime Matsumoto, an activist who operates from a thrift shop in Koenji, has amassed a large following at his protests and rallies. Some like-minded Japanese have opened their own stores alongside Mr. Matsumoto’s, huddling after hours to help hatch protest plans, turning Koenji into a center of activism.

“The poor man’s revolt has finally begun!” Mr. Matsumoto shouted at a recent demonstration, banging on a full set of drums perched atop a piece of plywood on wheels. His message: even poor people deserve a good life. “If we all get together, we can bring about change!”

Some experts question how much political influence demonstrators will wield. Few expect them to be a big force at the ballot box later this year when Japan holds parliamentary elections.

Young people are outnumbered by older voters, and are concentrated in cities, where ballots carry less weight, proportionally, than in the sparsely populated countryside.

Still, the nascent focus on worker and generational rights is a break from the years under the former nationalist prime ministers Shinzo Abe and Junichiro Koizumi. Then, stoked by nationalist rhetoric from politicians and government officials, youth seemed to swerve to the right. …

For now, the public has some sympathy with the protesters, and the rallies get heavy coverage in local media.

“I support these young people,” said Masaaki Saito, 60, an owner of a small electronics store in Koenji who took part in student protests in his youth.

“It’s been a long time,” he said, “but Japan’s youth are getting their voice back.”

Japan Offers $1.7 Billion Bailout for Chip Maker: here.

Southern damselflies in Devon, England


This is a video of mating southern damselflies.

From Wildlife Extra:

Southern damselflies released into Devon nature reserve

26/06/2009 16:33:18

Rare insect reintroduced to Devon heath

June 2009. Devon Wildlife Trust has staged the mass reintroduction of a globally threatened species into one of its reserves. Over the past week, 500 southern damselflies have been released at Venn Ottery Nature Reserve in East Devon.

30% decline in UK

The small iridescent blue insects are found at just five sites in Devon and the species has suffered a 30% decline in the UK since 1960. The dragonflies were transferred from Beaulieu Heath in the New Forest to the 25 hectare Devon Wildlife Trust SSSI using butterfly rearing cages. The insects were moved over the course of four days and were released successfully on to a 400 metre stretch of water course. …

DWT’s Nature Reserves Officer Ian Chadwick said: ‘Over 95% of the southern damselfly’s two-year lifecycle is spent as a larva living in submerged stream vegetation. A permanent supply of unpolluted, slow moving running water is essential for their survival. This work has enabled us to create the right conditions for the reintroduction and we are confident that it will succeed.’

July 2011: Volunteers at Devon Wildlife Trust have been the first to witness the return of the southern damselfly at Venn Ottery Nature Reserve following the successful re-introduction of 500 adults in 2009: here.

Wood white butterfly gets extra protection in Herefordshire: here.

Why is Herefordshire ignored by national conservation bodies? RSPB, we need you: here.

Basking shark births seen for the first time


This video is called Basking sharks filmed in Cornwall, England.

From Wildlife Extra:

Basking shark births witnessed for the first time

29/06/2009 09:45:42

Basking sharks have been breaching – Very unusual behaviour

June 2009. Snorkellers have witnessed basking shark behaviour never before seen anywhere in the world. Up to five basking shark pups have been born to two females during a mass gathering of the world’s second largest fish, off the coast of Cornwall.

900 Basking shark sightings

During the last month, the Cornwall Wildlife Trust, along with Seaquest, has run a surveying project funded by British International Helicopters. To date, the 40 trained volunteers have sighted a basking shark every day, with an estimated 900 sightings in total.

Basking shark breaching

Tom Hardy, marine conservation officer for Cornwall Wildlife Trust, has also reported six basking shark breaches during this period. Breaching is incredibly rare behaviour and was photographed in the UK for the first time in 2006.

According to Joan Edwards, head of marine policy for The Wildlife Trusts, this behaviour is usually only seen in large groups. She said: “This is a fantastic opportunity for science and to advance our understanding of this spectacular species. This just goes to show, what an important marine habitat the UK provides and enhances the importance of protecting such hotspots for this species.

“We just don’t know enough about their behaviour. There are theories about breaching being a form of communication linked to mating rituals or behaviour. It may be to do with males herding females. So we would issue a word of caution to people not to get too close to this supergroup. There is a risk of breach. And human contact may also have effects on the young or potentially the entire group.

Mating and reproduction

“This is fantastic timing. The Wildlife Trusts believe some areas of the South West coast and west of Scotland are seasonally very important areas for the mating and reproduction of basking sharks. The Marine and Coastal Access Bill, which will be discussed by MPs in Parliament next week, will hopefully provide us with the legislation that will allow us to establish Marine Conservation Zones for our marine wildlife, including basking sharks.”

Basking shark numbers

It is estimated the basking shark population in the north-east Atlantic has declined by more than 95% from historic levels. In the past, the major threat was hunting, and more than 80,000 basking sharks were killed in the north-east Atlantic. Now, with the fishery closed, the key threats arise from collisions with boats and entanglement in fishing gear.

Basking shark breeding

Basking sharks are slow-growing, late to reach sexual maturity at 12-20 years – and produce few young – bearing five or six pups for a gestation of one to three years. This makes them extremely vulnerable to over-exploitation. Even when threats are removed, numbers take a very long time to recover.

Basking shark survey

Between 1999 – 2007, The Wildlife Trusts’ basking shark survey counted, observed and photographed sharks off the UK’s western coasts. Volunteer crews were recruited from the membership of The Wildlife Trusts and Earthwatch Institute (Europe) to help with the surveys. All volunteers received full training in all aspects of appropriate survey technique, from observation procedures to data gathering and recording.

The survey revealed basking shark hotspots off the southwest of England, Northern Ireland and Scotland where they gather for feeding and courtship. The Manx Wildlife Trust has previously identified hotspots around the Isle of Man. For more information visit

http://www.manxbaskingsharkwatch.com/news.aspx

Basking shark strands in Cornwall: here.

New Australian frogs discovered


This video from Australia is called Kimberley Wildlife and Scientific Expedition.

From Wildlife Extra:

Two New Frogs Discovered in Western Australia

29/06/2009 12:48:18

June 2009. Two new species of frogs have been discovered in Western Australia according to the Western Australian Museum.

Tiny Toadlet

The first species is called the Tiny Toadlet (Uperoleia micra) and is just over 2 cm long. It was discovered near the Prince Regent River when it was first heard calling near the field expedition base camp at Bachsten Creek. The new species is extremely shy and would not have been discovered if its call did not differ from those of three related species in the area.

Toadlets are actually frogs

Toadlets‘ are not true toads, but a group of native frogs that have a stocky appearance. The Kimberley is host to the highest diversity of Toadlets in Australia.

Kimberley Froglet

The Kimberley Froglet (Crinia fimbriata), was discovered on the Mitchell Plateau – an area previously believed to have been well surveyed for frogs. It is also about 2 cm in length. It was noticed owing to its blue and red background colour and covered with tiny white dots, similar to some Aboriginal painting styles. Males of this species have flanges on the fingers, but it is not known what the flanges might be used for.

Kimberley biodiversity

The discovery of two frog species in the northwest Kimberley emphasises the high diversity of the area, and is timely owing to current State and National reviews of the area’s biodiversity assets. The very rugged northwest Kimberley region is being increasingly impacted by tourism, industry, feral weeds, cattle and soon the Cane Toad.

High level of endemism

Dr. Paul Doughty, WA Museum Curator of Herpetology said “The northwest Kimberley has a high diversity of frogs and reptiles that are unique to the region, as it receives high rainfall in summer and the area is cut-off by drier regions to the south. Many of the species that occur there have been evolving there in isolation for millions of years, and there are certainly more species to discover from the area.” …

The discovery of the frogs from the high rainfall zone of the northwest Kimberley were formally described this week in the Records of the Western Australian Museum and Zootaxa.

Australia: Green tree frog eats a snake – photo: here.

Dutch yellow-bellied toads: here.

More frog news here.

New species of high altitude frogs discovered in Peru – No tadpoles: here.

Frogs building nests by folding leaves: here.

Western Australia oil spill a potential disaster for marine life: here.

A strawberry poison dart frog mother checks up on her tadpole brood. Video here below.

Timber Harvest Impacts Amphibians Differently During Life Stages: here.

Appenine yellow-bellied toad (Bombina pachypus): here.

Museums sell art in economic crisis


Earlier today, on this blog, a “happy” item about one important work of art, now no longer owned by a private collector and invisible for the public, but bought (in this case with private subsidies) for people to see it in a museum.

Now, news about many works of art sold by museums, maybe to disappear for a long time, languishing in safes. From The Art Newspaper:

Robbing Peter to pay… who?

Deaccessioning rules have a strange interpretation of what constitutes the public interest

By Donn Zaretsky

As Lindsay Pollock reports in the July/August issue and on theartnewspaper.com, about a third of the works included in Christie’s 20 May sale in New York were from US museums.

One of those museums was the Montclair Art Museum in New Jersey, which, in March of this year, issued a very strange announcement. It revealed that, having “been deeply affected by the current financial crisis”, it was putting into place a “Financial Security Plan”, one part of which was the sale of more than 50 works from the collection, including an important 1951 drawing by Jackson Pollock.

What was strange about the announcement was how the proposed deaccessioning was supposed to fit into the “Financial Security Plan”. Under professional standards promulgated by the American Association of Museum Directors (AAMD) and the Association of American Museums (AAM), US museums can deaccession only to buy more work—and Montclair was quick to point out at every turn that they fully intended to comply with that rule. But if the sales proceeds were to be used to buy more work—simply replacing one set of objects with another—how could that possibly help make the museum more financially secure? …

In an article for the Wall Street Journal, critic James Panero seemed to have solved the mystery: the works were being sold to satisfy the requirements of the museum’s bonds. …

But why couldn’t the museum be honest about the reasons for the sale? Why not just say “we have to sell some work in order to satisfy our bond covenants”? Why go through the charade of emphasising that the proceeds will be “used solely to purchase works of art in the future”? …

Why is Montclair selling 50 works, including an important Pollock? (The director of the museum downplayed the sale by pointing out that “you can take a bus and be in [New York City] in 20 minutes, where you can see lots of work by Pollock.”)

Yeah right … OTHER work by Pollock. And if you’re a banking millionaire, bailed out by Jane and Joe Taxpayer, doing well, economic crisis or no crisis, you can go to Europe by private plane and see even more Pollocks … Yeah right.

As also reported in this issue, the Los Angeles County Museum of Art sold a cache of old master paintings at Sotheby’s on June 4 and the Orange County Museum of Art recently sold off a big part of its California impressionist collection. Why is it perfectly acceptable for museums to “raid the collections placed in trust” with them in this way?

And second, if the goal really is to make sure works held in the public trust stay there, then there’s a much simpler solution: require that museums sell only to other museums. (In fact, museum consultant Adrian Ellis made something close to just such a proposal in The Art Newspaper back in 2004.) If the Montclair Art Museum sold its Pollock to, say, the Metropolitan Museum of Art—just a 20 minute bus ride away!—it’s hard to see how “the public” would be hurt. The work would still remain “accessible to present and future generations”.

In fact, however, the best of the Lacma works were bought by a London dealer, and all 18 Orange County works went to a single unnamed private collector. Similarly, most of the Montclair works are ending up in private hands, no longer part of the “public trust.”