Maria, ‘stolen Aryan girl’ media lies, and anti-Roma racism

Maria, Roma girl, not 'stolen Aryan'

From daily The Guardian in Britain:

Maria is Roma – so now she will become invisible once more

When the glare of the media spotlight fades, Maria will go back to a life of exclusion, without basic documentation or rights

Zeljko Jovanovic

Monday 28 October 2013 16.28 GMT

Maria, the “mystery” girl taken away from a Roma couple in Greece was, DNA evidence has shown, the biological daughter of a Roma couple in Bulgaria. Blonde hair and blue eyes was evidence enough for police in Greece, and in two separate cases in Ireland, to take action. But now that it has emerged that Maria is a Roma child, it is painfully predictable that global interest in her fate will fade. Whatever the legal fate of the couple who have been charged with her abduction, Maria, like other Roma children, will have to navigate her way through life suffering illiteracy, unemployment, and segregation in education.

She will have on average 10 years lower life expectancy than the mainstream population due to hunger and malnutrition, squalid housing and substandard healthcare. If European governments or the wider community are really interested in helping Maria and other Roma children like her, they should start with ensuring access to basic documentation and fundamental rights.

I am Roma and have worked on social justice for many years. The incidents in Greece and Ireland should make it uncomfortably clear to the wider public how quickly Europe can still be whipped into a racist hysteria. They also however illustrate an issue that Roma rights groups have campaigned on for years. The lack of official documentation for Roma – highlighted in the absence of appropriate birth certificates and other papers in Maria’s case – is a major reason for Roma exclusion in Europe today.

No country in Europe has accurate statistics for Roma citizens in their official census or other state records. Many Roma do not have birth certificates either; Roma families often forgo registering the birth of a child with local authorities as the cost of obtaining a birth certificate can be prohibitive. Because of this official invisibility, Roma are denied legal protection, public healthcare and the opportunity to enrol their children in school, get a job and register to vote. It also means Roma are at increased risk of human trafficking and miscarriages of justice. If you do not officially exist, it is easy to disappear and be disappeared.

The gaps in official census records for Roma are staggering. A recent census registration campaign carried out by the Open Society Foundations and Roma communities in Hungary achieved a 63% increase in the registered Roma population, from 190,000 to more than 300,000. Huge disparities remain. In Serbia, the 2012 census registered 190,000 Roma; the real number is closer to 300,000.

Some Roma do not officially register their identity due to fear of discrimination. Only six decades ago hatemongers and political leaders sent more than half a million Roma to their deaths for the “collective crime” of simply being Roma; this memory lives on among Roma. Their suspicion of registration is not unfounded. In a recent case in Sweden it was revealed that the police kept a secret and illegal list of more than 4,000 Roma, including many children.

More often, deliberate legal and procedural difficulties put in place by governments restrict Roma from securing proper documentation. A fully documented and registered Roma population means governments must provide fundamental rights such as access to education, healthcare and justice; they must fulfil public job quotas for Roma and include a quota of Roma politicians on electoral rolls. For many governments in Europe, Roma invisibility is politically and economically expedient.

Without official identification documents or legal claims to their property, Roma families are at increased risk of statelessness. A stateless person is not recognised as a citizen by any state. This is important because citizenship is the essential foundation of a person’s legal identity. It is your right to have rights. Many Roma in Europe today are trapped in this legal limbo. One example that illustrates the fate of thousands of Roma is Tarmis Urmin, who fled Kosovo in 1999 to a Roma settlement in Belgrade. Urmin had made the 150km trek to Serbia’s registration office in a vain attempt to obtain documentation. Because his wife has no documents, his four children cannot get documents either. “When I brought my youngest child to be vaccinated the medical staff demanded 2,000 dinars (about €25)” Urmin recounted. “I had no money and could not afford it. They shouted at me and my family that if we know how to make children we should know how to get documents.”

Statelessness exists in western Europe too. Italy is home to thousands of Roma families, many of whom are stateless or at risk of it. They exist in legal limbo, lacking official citizenship for any country, deprived of fundamental civil, political, economic, cultural, and social rights.

Europe’s 12 million Roma continue to endure violent attacks, firebombings and serial killings, yet their official invisibility can be just as deadly.

Roma Stereotypes: How Racist Assumptions Fueled ‘Maria’ Fiasco: here.

Cops break up families in search of racist Roma myth: here.

Roma under attack in Greece speak out – ‘We are human and we want justice’: here.

Persecution of Roma stepped up after “blond angel” child trafficking allegations: here.

Greek media rapped by ombudsman over Maria reports: here.

On October 28, 1913, Menahem Mendel Beilis, a Ukrainian Jew who was the victim of an infamous anti-Semitic frame-up orchestrated by the Tsarist autocracy, was acquitted of the murder of an eleven-year-old boy. The acquittal took place in the context of an international outcry over the persecution of Beilis, who was accused of murdering the child as part of a blood ritual, an archetype of anti-Semitic propaganda: here.

13 thoughts on “Maria, ‘stolen Aryan girl’ media lies, and anti-Roma racism

  1. I am of Roma descent; my grandfather was unusual in having blue eyes and my mother and myself are the only two with naturally blonde hair and fair skin. My mother has her father’s blue/grey eyes whilst I have my own father’s cobalt blue. My dark haired, dark skinned, green eyed son looks far more Roma than I do, as he takes after his dark but decidedly non-Roma father.

    I have been trying to educate people about the Roma Ways; it is perfectly possible that Maria has been passed among many Roma families, as this is natural to them; community equals family to the Roma, and many children are not with their biological parents for many reasons. Perhaps her Bulgarian parents briefly shared community with the Greek couple, and needed somebody to care for Maria because they already had too many children, or because on or both parents fell ill. There are a myriad reasons as to why Maria might have been passed to the Greek couple.

    Thank you for passing this article along, and for highlighting the plight of Roma worldwide.


  2. Pingback: Anti-Roma racism in Europe | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: French racist Le Pen’s anti-Roma hate speech | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: Britons reject governmental anti-eastern European xenophobia | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  5. Pingback: Keep Hungarian nazi fuehrer out of London | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  6. Pingback: European governmental anti-Roma bigotry | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  7. Pingback: Belgian xenophobic mayor’s ‘musical’ anti-Roma plan backfires | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  8. Pingback: Madonna warns against French neo-fascism | Dear Kitty. Some blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.