Abortion, Irish referendum victory, United States problems

This video says about itself:

Ireland votes to lift abortion ban in landslide referendum | ITV News

26 May 2018

‘Yes’ campaigners celebrated a “resounding” victory as Ireland voted overwhelmingly to change its restrictive laws on abortion.

As voters chose to repeal the Eighth Amendment, Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar said that a “quiet revolution” had taken place.

By Patrick Martin in the USA:

The abortion vote in Ireland: A blow against reaction

29 May 2018

The overwhelming “Yes” vote in the Irish referendum on abortion rights, by a margin of 1,429,981 votes for and 723,632 votes against, is a landmark victory both for the Irish working class and for the defense of democratic rights internationally. In a country that for centuries has been synonymous with domination by the medieval backwardness of the Roman Catholic Church, where as recently as 20 years ago both contraception and divorce were illegal, two-thirds of those voting in a heavy turnout supported the legalization of abortion. It is a demonstration that, while the official parties of bourgeois Europe are all moving to the right, the working class and sections of the middle class are moving to the left.

Last Friday’s vote is an exact reversal of the 1983 referendum which enacted the Eighth Amendment to the Irish constitution, formally prohibiting abortion by giving the unborn fetus legal rights equal to those of a pregnant woman. That referendum, backed by the Catholic hierarchy and Ireland’s major parties, passed by a two-to-one margin. The referendum to repeal the Eight Amendment was opposed by the hierarchy, but the bishops avoided a prominent public role because of a series of major scandals that have shattered the Church’s claims to infallibility and moral superiority, involving sexual abuse by priests, enslavement of women in convent enterprises, and the discovery of a mass grave of at least 800 children born “out of wedlock” over many decades in rural Tuam, dumped in the septic tank of a Catholic home for unwed mothers.

The main … parties—Fine Gael, Fianna Fail, Labour and Sinn Fein—all officially endorsed a “yes” vote, although the two largest, Fine Gael and Fianna Fail, were deeply split. In any case, as observers noted, these parties were not leading the campaign to legalize abortion, they were trailing behind a popular movement that was manifested in a major influx of new voters, the Internet-based crowd-funding of the “yes” campaign, and enthusiastic participation among youth, and particularly young women.

Vote tabulations found that only one district out of 40, Donegal, on the border with Northern Ireland, reported a majority “no” vote, and that by a narrow margin. Even the most rural and conservative areas, such as Roscommon and Mayo, posted majorities for “yes”. Exit polls revealed that support for abortion rights won a majority among every age group except those over 65 (with 80 percent or more among young people voting “yes”), and among urban, suburban and rural voters. Irish farmers voted by 52.5 percent to defy the Catholic Church, which had branded every “yes” vote a sin requiring confession and repentance.

There are both short-term and long-term social factors at work in the shift in public opinion in Ireland. As one Irish commentator noted, the campaign to repeal the Eighth Amendment was spearheaded by the youth: “this campaign has been largely won by a generation that had good reason to give up on Ireland. It is the generation of 2008, the generation that was handed a massive bank debt, that was told there were no jobs, that had its wages and welfare payments cut, that was informed, in so many words, that it would be greatly appreciated if it would kindly remove itself to somewhere else.”

Real wages plummeted after the 2008 financial crash, which put an end to widespread illusions in Ireland as the “Celtic Tiger”, but have recovered somewhat since 2012. Meanwhile, the cost of living has continued its relentless rise. Dublin, which accounts for one quarter of the country’s population, is now a more expensive place to live than London. Economic inequality in Ireland, as in all the major capitalist countries, has risen to previously unheard-of levels. Not since Anglo-Irish landlords feasted while their peasant tenants starved during the Great Famine of 1847–48 has the gap between the wealthy and the rest of the population been so vast.

But there is another social transformation, of a longer-term and more profound character, that is manifested in the Irish vote. Once a country consisting overwhelmingly of poor farmers, usually tenants at the mercy of the landlord and priest, Ireland has undergone an industrial development and economic modernization over the past half century. In 1960, only 46 percent of Ireland’s 2.8 million population lived in urban areas, while 54 percent were rural. In 2018, 67 percent of Ireland’s 4.8 million population lives in urban areas, with only 33 percent rural. The transformation in raw numbers is even more remarkable: Ireland’s urban population has risen 150 percent, from 1,288,000 in 1960 to 3,216,000; the rural population has risen by only 11 percent over the same period, from 1,512,000 to 1,684,000.

What the influx of capital investment in factories, offices and research centers means in class terms is unmistakable: the urban working class, once a relatively small minority in Ireland, albeit with a remarkable revolutionary history, is now the largest social force in the country; the rural tenantry and farmers, long dominated by the Catholic Church, have become a minority. And it is the working class, of all classes in modern capitalist society, which is the bedrock for the defense of democratic rights.

Over the past quarter century, in a series of referendums that have allowed the people to override the bourgeois parties that kowtow to the Church, Ireland has legalized contraception, divorce, gay marriage and now abortion. As the New York Times noted Monday, “The culture of silence and deference to religious authority that long dominated Ireland is gone.”

It is instructive to contrast the advances in democratic rights recorded in what was once the most backward country in western Europe, with the frontal assault on those rights in the United States, the richest and most powerful capitalist country in the world. Once legislation is enacted by the Irish parliament—already presented in draft form before the referendum—women in small towns and rural areas of Ireland will have greater access to reproductive health care, including abortion, than their counterparts in similar areas of the United States.

In 2014, according to the Guttmacher Institute, there was no abortion provider in 90 percent of US counties, accounting for 39 percent of the women of reproductive age. This included 99 percent of counties in Missouri, 98 percent in the Dakotas and Kentucky, 97 percent in Arkansas, and 96 percent in Wisconsin. One-quarter of women who needed abortion services had to travel at least 25 miles to find a clinic. In parts of Texas and the Great Plains, the distance to be traveled comes to hundreds of miles each way.

The right to abortion is being destroyed by stealth, through a combination of state harassment of clinics, such as requirements that they be affiliated to hospitals (even when the only local hospital is Catholic), and obstacles placed in the way of women, such as the requirement of multiple visits to receive “counseling” before they obtain the procedure. Heavy pressure has been placed on insurance companies, most recently by the Trump administration, not to cover abortion services in any government-linked insurance plan, such as Obamacare. Medicaid will not pay for the procedure, and funding for the largest provider of abortion services, Planned Parenthood, is under systematic attack.

This assault on democratic rights affects primarily women of the working class. Women of higher income and social position have no problem obtaining abortion and other reproductive health services when they need them. …

This [United States corporate media] indifference carries over to the media coverage of the Irish referendum. It has dropped from the newspaper headlines after one day. It barely registered in the network news broadcasts. The World Socialist Web Site sees this issue differently. We hail the actions of the Irish people, who have dealt a blow to reaction. This vote reinforces our conviction that the defense of democratic rights, and of all progressive developments in modern society, requires the mobilization of the strength of the working class as an independent political force.

Women march for access to safe abortions in Argentina: here.

A new report cites the devastating impact of the Trump administration’s “Protecting Life in Global Health Assistance” policy. In January 2017 Trump instituted his version of the so-called Mexico City Policy, otherwise known by its critics as the “global gag rule,” or GGR, which essentially blocks US federal funding for international organizations that provide counseling, referrals or services for abortion in low-income nations. The report, “Prescribing Chaos in Global Health: The Global Gag Rule from 1984-2018 ,” was released Tuesday by the Center for Health and Gender Equity (CHANGE). CHANGE President Serra Sippel wrote in a letter accompanying the report that Trump’s expanded policy “has had immediate, direct, and potentially devastating ramifications, not only for women’s health, but for all health services for women, men and children”: here.

20 thoughts on “Abortion, Irish referendum victory, United States problems

  1. Pingback: Irish religious forced labour survivors meet | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  2. Pingback: Donald Trump’s unwelcome visit to Britain | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: US supreme court supports Trump’s xenophobia, misogyny | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominees | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  5. Pingback: Trump packs US Supreme Court with far-rightists | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  6. Pingback: Latin American feminist struggle | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  7. Pingback: Anti-democratic far-right education in Michigan, USA | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  8. Pingback: Irish voters remove blasphemy from constitution, re-elect president | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  9. Pingback: Roman Catholic and other clerical child abuse | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  10. Senator Susan Collins built a career calling herself a “pro-choice Republican” who stands up for women’s rights.1

    But then she voted to confirm Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh–the fifth vote to end Roe v. Wade.

    Last week, Sen. Collins voted against abortion rights AGAIN, supporting a bill that smears women and abortion providers as murderers.2

    UltraViolet Action is holding Sen. Collins accountable by making sure Mainers know the truth about her anti-choice votes. Will you chip in $5?

    Yes, I’ll donate $5 to help hold Susan Collins accountable to her anti-choice votes.

    Sen. Collins talks a big game about reproductive rights. She once said she wanted Republicans to be “synonymous with a woman’s right to choose.”3 She calls herself pro-choice and has vowed to protect women’s health care.4

    But when Sen. Collins had the chance to stop Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh and truly protect Roe v. Wade, she sold out every woman in America.

    Now that she’s shown her true colors, it seems that Sen. Collins is going to keep trampling reproductive rights. Last week, she voted for an extreme bill that would threaten prison time for doctors who treat women facing the most heartbreaking complications later in pregnancy.5

    The goal of this bill is to demonize women and doctors and make it more politically feasible for the Supreme Court to end Roe v. Wade. But Sen. Collins voted for it anyway. It’s time that Sen. Susan Collins was held accountable to her anti-choice record, and we’re going to make sure Maine people know how she is voting to take away reproductive rights.

    Will you chip in $5 to help hold Susan Collins accountable to her anti-choice record?

    Thank you for joining in.

    –Shaunna, Kat, Karin, Holly, Kathy, Susan, Anathea, Audine, Emma, Pilar, Natalie, Melody, Lindsay, Pam, Ryan, Sonja, and Noma, the UltraViolet Action team



    1. Susan Collins says Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh won’t end abortion rights in the US, Quartz, October 5, 2018

    2. Senate defeats anti-abortion bill, as GOP tries to jam Dems, Politico, February 25, 2019

    3. Susan Collins’ Choice, Slate, September 5, 2018

    4. Susan Collins’s Reputation as a Moderate Is On the Line, The Nation, September 12, 2018

    5. Senator Murray: Democrats Stand With Doctors, Nurses, Women Against Latest GOP Show Vote Attacking Women’s Rights And Health Care, United States Senator Patty Murray, February 19, 2019


  11. Pingback: United States women’s rights demonstrators interviewed | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  12. Pingback: US politician Biden’s flip-flop on abortion | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  13. Pingback: US presidential candidate Buttigieg flip-flops on abortion | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  14. Pingback: British Conservatives ally with Spanish Franco fascists | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  15. Pingback: Right-wing YouTube, left-wing YouTube | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  16. Pingback: British Conservative Rees-Mogg attacks Grenfell fire victims | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  17. Pingback: Trump’s far-right State of the Union speech | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  18. Pingback: Siouxsie, straight edge women, other punk research | Dear Kitty. Some blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.