Mumbai, India flooding like Houston, USA


This video from India says about itself:

Waterlogged Mumbai: Water enters hospitals, disrupts festivity; BMC claims all well

29 August 2017

Whole year municipality sat over doing nothing to get prepared for the rainfalls in Mumbai. As a result Mumbai has almost come to a halt after heavy rainfall since Saturday. Rainfall is natural but had Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) cleared the garbage and slits blocking manholes and the drainage system then water logging would not have taken place.

The BMC did not even consider that the city is celebrating Ganesh Chaturthi. Due to the lacuna of BMC, city roads are waterlogged compelling many Ganesha puja committees to think of alternatives. Sarvajanik Ganeshotsav Samiti in Mumbai has issued advisory to Ganapati mandals to disconnect power supplies if required. Well, if this was not enough then BMC must reply over water entering hospitals including at KEM Hospital’s ground floor. 30 patients shifted to upper floors. Refuting all allegations, BMC has jumped to face saving mode and claimed the situation is well under control and advised Mumbaikars to stay indoors.

Like in Houston, USA, global warming, caused by the fossil fuel industry’s drive for profits, increases storms and downpours in the Indian subcontinent to destructive proportions. More than 1,000 people have already died in South Asia by floods this summer.

UPDATE Dutch NOS TV, 30 August 2017: 1,500 people dead in India, Nepal and Bangladesh.

According to NOS TV today, the flooding in Mumbai has killed at least six people and destroyed homes.

I wish strength and recovery for all survivors of this terrible disaster.

Like in Houston, USA, less people would have died, less homes would have been destroyed and there would have been less damage to local businesses if ‘developers’ would not have paved over wetlands which might have absorbed the rain. Like in Houston, and elsewhere in India, this is also a problem in Mumbai.

From the Hindustan Times in India:

Mumbai wetland destruction: 5-acre wetland patch destroyed through debris dumping, Thane collector to ensure action

A five-acre wetland patch along the Thane-Nashik highway, next to Kharegaon creek, has been illegally reclaimed through the dumping of debris by unidentified people on Wednesday.

Apr 05, 2017 10:49 IST

In this case, it was an illegal act by ‘unidentified people’. However, similar, but legal, acts by well-respected millionaire ‘developers’, with the connivance of politicians, are probably a still bigger problem.

From Scroll.in in India, by Darryl D’Monte:

A state-made disaster: How Mumbai’s civic body let the rain swallow the city (yet again)

Wednesday, August 30th 2017

Despite the July 2005 deluge, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation and other authorities are no better prepared to deal with heavy rain.

By allowing Mumbai to go under yet again on Tuesday, the Shiv Sena [far-right sectarian ultra-fundamentalist Hindu political party]-led Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation has shown – if at all any proof was necessary – that it is incapable of managing such a complex city. That the monsoon will see heavy rainfall days is known and the city ought to have been better prepared for it, as is reiterated every year.

Glib excuses about how the rainfall crossed a certain threshold or citing the city’s geography as a reason for the annual chaos will no longer hold. One could argue precisely the opposite: because the city is a peninsula, hemmed in by the sea on two sides, a proper drainage system would have ensured that water does not accumulate in the very same spots, year after year.

In what some weathermen are claiming to be the heaviest rainfall in Mumbai since the July 2005 cloudburst, when 944 mm of rain lashed down in 24 hours, the city received more than 298 mm of rainfall between 8 am and 5 pm on Tuesday and the figure for 24 hours is likely to be much higher. Unsurprisingly, the city came to a standstill – people had to wade though waist-high water in some areas, roads were flooded and train services disrupted. This even as an over two-decade old plan to revamp the drainage system in the city is still only partially implemented.

Down the drain

In June 1985, after a heavy downpour, the Mumbai municipal corporation appointed British consultants Watson Hawksly to prepare a plan that would allow the city to tackle up to 50 mm of rainfall an hour. The consultants took eight years to submit their report and the municipal corporation took another 12 years to implement it. The plan was called the Brihanmumbai Storm Water Drainage report, better known by its tongue-twister of an acronym, BRIMSTOWAD. It proposed, among other things, to instal pumping stations to drain the roads and to upgrade the city’s British-era drainage system. While many activists were initially sceptical of the plan, the report is now described as a milestone drainage blueprint for the city.

According to the Mumbai Vikas Samiti, a think-tank comprising top retired municipal engineers that was formed after the July 26, 2005 deluge, the consultants examined the network of existing drains and nullahs more than 1.5 metres wide and divided it into 121 catchments. In a report released this July, on the 12th anniversary of the floods, the Samiti cited how the consultants “studied deficiencies, identified difficulties in cleaning, maintenance, reviewed desilting criteria and prepared a Master Plan for the augmentation of the storm water drainage system”.

The project’s total cost was a modest Rs 616 crores, based on 1992 estimates, and was to be carried out over 12 years. By 2017, the munipality had only spent Rs 260 crores. “Major recommendations were not carried out, such as those for pumping stations, renovation of old drains, widening of railway culverts, diversion of flow, removal of obstructions of water mains, cables etc in the drainage system, installation of flood gates, widening and deepening of nullahs etc,” noted the Samiti. “The systematic cleaning of underground drains and desilting of nullahs was also not carried out properly before the onset of the monsoon.”

Water everywhere

Drainage networks apart, the city is also blessed with an nature-gifted flood relief system, by virtue of its many rivers and canals. But it was was only in 2005 that the city seemingly woke up to the fact that the Mithi, far from being a filthy drain into the Mahim Bay, was actually a river. It is in fact the overflow from the Tulsi, Vihar and Powai lakes, the first two of which originate in the 110 sq km Sanjay Gandhi National Park – all of which give Mumbai its distinct ecological identity. Mithi River was so badly encroached upon and used as a dumping ground that when Mumbai received 944 mm of rainfall on that fateful July day, three-quarters of it in five hours between 2.30 pm and 7.30 pm, nature stuck back with fury, leaving death and destruction in its wake.

The Mumbai municipality is dimly aware, if at all, that there are three other rivers in the city proper – the Poisar, Oshiwara and Dahisar – that course through the megapolis like major arteries and deserve to be kept free of filth to allow storm water to drain freely.

According to architect and activist PK Das, whose Open Mumbai exhibition in 2013 mapped the entire city, including its slums and open spaces, Mumbai’s major nullahs form a vein-like network that can extend for an astounding 300 km. These could have functioned effectively to drain water out of the city. But this is a natural legacy that the city authorities have abused, with the reckless sanctioning of building after building, in brazen collusion with builders and venal bureaucrats. By indiscriminately dumping waste in open drains, citizens have also contributed to choking them.

Das has shown by reviving the Irla nullah in the Juhu Vile Parle Development scheme how these can prove both functional in absorbing excess rain as well serve as an excellent site for recreation and cultural activities.

Ecologically, the city is also blessed with other natural sponges, such as mangroves, wetlands and salt pans, which soak up water and hence prevent flooding. Over the years, many of these have been given away by government authorities to developers to construct supposed affordable housing and the like.

The municipality can’t throw up its hands and claim that it does not have the funds to tackle such torrential rain and floods. It is, after all, the country’s richest civic body. First and foremost, the city should upgrade its weather forecasting system. Tuesday’s downpour was not a local phenomenon but part of a major depression that had set in over the previous couple of days and will travel to Gujarat. The disaster management department should put such a system in place at the earliest. After all, the state government spent Rs 200 crores on relief during the 2005 floods and citizens bear the cost of dealing with such disasters, which can be predicted with modern-day equipment.

The most shocking demonstration of its incompetence is that the richest municipal corporation in the country, with budgets exceeding that of some states, does spend much money on infrastructure. For 2017-’18, the civic body’s budget is Rs 25,141 crores, a 30% reduction from last year’s Rs 37,052 crores. But in the last 10 years, of a total budget of Rs 2.19 lakh crores, the civic body has reportedly spent only 18%, or some Rs 40,000 crores, on creating infrastructure. That amounts to just Rs 4,000 crores a year.

To add insult to injury, the corporation reportedly is sitting on Rs 61,500 crores of fixed deposits that could have been spent on building infrastructure and improving civic amenities. The interest on this alone would amount to over Rs 4,500 crores a year.

At a time when Hurricane Harvey has brought Houston and other parts of Texas to its knees, Mumbai’s authorities should be aware that the threat of a massive cyclone is no longer a distant possibility in the city, as Indian Ocean surface temperatures steadily rise with climate change. Such a calamity could bring far greater destruction than a heavy monsoon downpour. Will Mumbai be prepared?

Darryl D’Monte is Chairman Emeritus, Forum of Environmental Journalists in India.

Mumbai high rise building collapses, probably because of rainfall. At least twelve people dead.

While floods have partially receded in the Indian states of Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Assam, the death toll from the disaster is now 1,300, with an estimated 45 million people affected throughout South Asia: here.

Hurricane Harvey: Indian student dies in Texas hospital after being rescued from lake: here.

12 thoughts on “Mumbai, India flooding like Houston, USA

    • At least in rich/NATO countries corporate media far less than the flooding in Houston, USA.

      I do think there should be coverage about Houston as well as South Asia. As long as it is CRITICAL coverage which does not neglect the causes of the disaster in Thatcherite-Reaganite-Bushite-Trumpite capitalism/politics. My blog and some other non-corporate media try to have such coverage.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Pingback: Houston, USA flood disaster | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  2. Pingback: Flood disaster in Texas, USA | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: Harvey flood disaster in Texas, USA | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: Hurricane Irma, from Caribbean to Florida, USA | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  5. Pingback: London solidarity with murdered Indian journalist | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  6. Pingback: Flood disaster in South Asia | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  7. Pingback: British Conservative attack on Indian, Bangladeshi curry | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  8. Pingback: Australia’s lethal climate change bushfires | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  9. Pingback: Indians demonstrate against religious discrimination | Dear Kitty. Some blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.