Clare Short on British Thatcherism-Blairism-Brownism

This is a video from Britain about David Miliband and his broken promise of a referendum on the European Union constitutional proposals.

From British daily The Independent:

Clare Short: How can Miliband be the answer to Labour‘s ills?

Our Foreign Secretary continues to spread suffering and anger across the Muslim world

Tuesday, 5 August 2008

The summer, when parliament closes down and people go on holiday, is famously known as the silly season. New Labour is certainly celebrating it in spectacular style.

It seems that the Blairites have decided that they have had enough of Gordon Brown and are planning a leadership challenge led by the young David Miliband.

They have obviously lost control of their senses. The first problem is that most normal people have never heard of David Miliband. He became head of policy for Tony Blair at age 29. In 2001, he had a parliamentary seat arranged for him by Tony Blair. He was immediately made minister for schools and supported the regime of endless testing and league tables that is so badly damaging our educational system. In the run-up to the Iraq war, I spoke to him to ask if he couldn’t prevent Tony from making such a terrible mistake. He said that he was keeping out of it.

After that, he went straight into the Cabinet, with responsibility for the environment, and seemed, for a moment, to be radicalised by the threat of global warming. There was vague talk of him running against Gordon Brown for the leadership, but he had no chance of winning and he soon pledged his support for Brown and was rewarded with the post of Foreign Secretary. Many thought that Brown had appointed someone who looked as though he was a clever sixth-former on work experience to enhance his own gravitas.

Miliband tells us he has enjoyed being Foreign Secretary, but he has made no changes in the foreign policy that made Blair so profoundly unpopular in the UK. He continues to support Bush’s policy towards the Middle East, which breaches international law and continues to spread suffering and anger across the Arab and Muslim world. And he has also made no change in relation to the mounting problem of Afghanistan.

So the question is, how can the Blairites think that David Miliband is the answer? Have they already forgotten how unpopular Blair had become by the time he left office? In 1997 Labour won 13.52 million votes, 450,000 more than Wilson won, which gave him a narrow majority in 1966. In 2005 Blair won 9.54 million votes, the second-lowest Labour vote in post-war Britain.

It is simply false to suggest that Blair put forward a massive new coalition. The rise of the third party, and historically poor performance of the Tories, explains the electoral victories. But in 2005, the election when Blair got so panicked he had to ditch Alan Milburn [see also here and here and here and here] and send for Brown, New Labour only won 2 in 10 of those registered to vote and 2 in 6 of the votes cast.

It is notable that when Gordon Brown took over, his popularity soared. He suggested he was going to change policy. He seemed to distance himself from Iraq policy and from Bush and said there would be more consultation and less spin. People were full of hope. And then he almost called an election, but didn’t. He made a terrible policy decision by abolishing the 10p rate and increasing the tax on the low paid so that he could outdo the Tories as a tax-cutter. And since then, he has changed nothing that Blair had left behind. The country was duly disappointed and on top of this the economy turned down.

My own view is that Brown’s tragedy is that he did not have the courage to turn in a social democratic direction. Even now, there is much he could do. The most urgent foreign policy crisis lies in the Middle East. Britain should break away from its poodle role and join with others to reshape policy and stand up for international law.

He should also listen to those who work in the public services, slim down the burden of bureaucratic targets and endless reorganisation and give back the authority to innovate at local level. On the environment, we need action, not words. Sweden is phasing out the use of fossil fuels by 2020. We could do the same, encourage ground source heat pumps instead of gas, cut everyone’s bill and massively reduce emissions. There is much more that would be possible in the 22 months that remain.

Those who want to save Labour from a dreadful result in 2010 need to look at the reality rather than their own propaganda. Blairism was a failure. Brown’s problem is that he doesn’t have the guts to return to his social democratic roots. David Miliband will not become the leader. The system makes a challenge almost impossible. The Blairites have learned no lessons from Blair’s failure and have made no policy proposals. They are simply creating division and bitterness that will make the Labour defeat even worse.

The writer was the international development secretary from 1997 until 2003. She resigned the Labour whip in 2006.

Clare Short had the courage to resign from Tony Blair’s administration in 2003, which is more than can be said about the others in that administration. A pity she and others did not resign before that war, sending Blair crashing down and preventing that war from starting.

8 thoughts on “Clare Short on British Thatcherism-Blairism-Brownism

  1. Candidates on attack after Darlington MP’s expenses order

    6:00am Monday 8th February 2010

    CANDIDATES hoping to replace Alan Milburn as Darlington MP have gone on the attack after it was revealed he had to pay back thousands of pounds in expenses.

    Last week, The Northern Echo reported that Mr Milburn had returned £11,000 of wrongly claimed expenses for mortgage interest and council tax claims on his second home in London.

    Mr Milburn, who lives in Northumberland and is standing down at the next General Election, said he was deeply embarrassed and blamed careless administration.

    Last night, Tory parliamentary candidate Edward Legard said: “Alan Milburn will not be held to account by the people of Darlington for taking taxpayers’ money to which he was not entitled.

    “He has cleverly stepped aside before that can happen.

    “Mr Milburn attributes his £11,000 over-claim to careless administration.

    “Ordinary people in Darlington will simply not accept this as an excuse.

    “Anyone accused of taking £11,000 in similar circumstances would not have had the luxury of avoiding pun- By David Roberts ishment by pleading careless administration.

    “They would have ended up facing a jury.

    “Mr Milburn’s former personal assistant is now standing in his place.

    “I look forward to her public and unequivocal condemnation of her former boss.”

    Mr Legard was referring to Jenny Chapman, Labour’s parliamentary candidate. She worked as a researcher for Mr Milburn until she left in 2002 to have a baby.

    Despite her political allegiance, she also criticised Mr Milburn, and said: “Alan Milburn has been a hardworking local MP, who wanted the best for Darlington. Having said that, there are things I would do differently.

    “I disagreed at the time, and disagree now, with Alan moving out of Darlington.

    “I am shocked and feel let down by all of the hundreds of MPs who have abused the expenses system, such as it was.

    “We need a new generation of MPs with more energy and a new attitude. I will always live in Darlington because it is my home and where I grew up.

    “I also promise that I will never abuse any future expenses system and that I will publish details of anything I claim.”

    Lib Dem candidate Mike Barker said: “I do not think he has devoted himself to the town the way he should have done in the past few years, and it now appears he has been milking the system for all he is worth.

    “Most people will be glad to see the back of him.

    “Given the amount of time he has spent in Darlington on his job in the last few years, he should be paying back half his salary as well.”


  2. Pingback: Tony Blair wants still more bloodshed in Syria and Iraq | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: Bloodthirsty Blair blasted by British peace movement | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: Rupert Murdoch’s empire, new book | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  5. Pingback: Stop British governmental Iraq war cover-up | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  6. Pingback: Tony Blair, new book | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  7. Pingback: Tony Blair, forever guilty of Iraq bloodbath, his ex-minister Short says | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  8. Pingback: Tony Blair, enemy of democracy | Dear Kitty. Some blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.