Human Rights Watch criticized for being uncritical of United States government


This video from the USA is called War on democracy – Media as a weapon in Venezuela coup attempt.

By Joe Emersberger in Australia:

The failure of Human Rights Watch in Venezuela and Haiti

7 March 2008

The way US-based Human Rights Watch (HRW) reported on Haiti and Venezuela in its 2008 World Report reveals an underlying assumption that the US and its allies have the right to overthrow democratic governments.

The Venezuela section of the report said nothing about ongoing attempts by the US to overthrow the government of President Hugo Chavez. It is a matter of public record that the US-funded groups who were involved in the military coup of 2002 that briefly overthrew Chavez, and continued to do so after the coup took place. US-Venezuelan lawyer Eva Golinger revealed the extent of this funding in great detail in The Chavez Code. …

HRW also used the 2008 World Report to criticise, yet again, a judicial reform law that was passed by the Chavez administration in 2004.

In contrast, HRW’s summary about Haiti said nothing about the coup that ousted Jean Bertrand Aristide’s democratically-elected government in 2004; nothing about the subsequent murder of thousands of people who supported Aristide’s Lavalas movement (the word “Lavalas” does not even appear in the summary); nothing about the fact that Haiti’s police and judiciary remain stacked with appointees from the dictatorship of 2004-2006; nothing about Father Gerard Jean Juste, the most prominent political prisoner of that period, who continues to be hounded by Haiti’s legal system.

2 thoughts on “Human Rights Watch criticized for being uncritical of United States government

  1. Truth suffers in Human Rights Watch report on Venezuela

    By the Venezuela Information Office

    On September 18, 2008 Human Rights Watch released a report entitled
    “Venezuela: Rights Suffer Under Chávez.” The report contains biases and
    inaccuracies, and wrongly purports that human rights guarantees are
    lacking or not properly enforced in Venezuela. In addition, while
    criticising Venezuela’s human rights in the political context, it fails
    to mention the many significant advancements made by the government on
    other essential human rights, such as access to education, healthcare,
    nutritious food, clean water and housing.

    * Read more http://links.org.au/node/633

    Like

  2. Human Rights Watch report on Venezuela: An echo of US propaganda

    Statement by the Australia-Venezuela Solidarity Network
    September 30, 2008 — As a broad network of organisations and
    individuals that has closely studied the significant changes in
    Venezuelan society since 1998 – including organising eight study tours
    to Venezuela involving more than 150 Australians from diverse
    backgrounds — we are obliged to respond to the biases, distortions and
    lies contained in the Human Rights Watch report A Decade Under Chavez:
    Political Intolerance and Lost Opportunities for Advancing Human Rights
    in Venezuela, released in September 2008.

    * Read more http://links.org.au/node/656

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.