censors criticism of Hillary Clinton’s book

This 6 September 2017 video from the USA is called Clinton‘s New Book Is Chock Full Of Bernie Blame.

Hillary Clinton made Donald Trump president. Whom does she blame for it? Herself? No, you guessed it … Bernie Sanders; who would have beaten Trump.

By Andre Damon in the USA:

Why is Amazon deleting negative reviews of Hillary Clinton’s new book?

15 September 2017

Amazon, the world’s largest online reseller, has deleted over 1,000 negative comments on Hillary Clinton’s newly-released book, What Happened, to give the book a five-star rating.

The book’s Amazon user rating is higher than the most popular editions of War and Peace and A Tale of Two Cities, widely considered to be among the greatest books ever written.

Early on Wednesday, the day of its release, the book had an extremely low rating of two and a half stars, based on nearly 1,700 reviews. But that figure was slashed to just over 500 later in the day, and stands at 623 at the time of this writing. The rating shot up to 4.9, rounded up to five stars in the graphic shown to users.

Amazon sought to justify this blatant act of mass censorship. “We do however have mechanisms in place to ensure that the voices of many do not drown out the voices of a few and we remove customer reviews that violate our community guidelines,” an Amazon spokesperson told Fortune magazine.

As a result of these actions, the book has just 21 “critical” reviews and 602 “positive” ones. This is despite the fact that the top seven most popular customer reviews gave it one or two stars.

As a work of political writing, Clinton’s book does not deserve the perfect score that Amazon gives it.

Leaving aside interpretation and opinion, its description of the key events of the 2016 election presents a level of selectiveness that borders on falsification. It ignores the widely-documented bias inside the Democratic National Committee toward the Clinton campaign, including the rigging of several debates, which led to the resignation of Debbie Wasserman Schultz as the head of the DNC, and engages in wild conspiracy theories about Russian intervention into the election campaign that it does not substantiate.

About half the book is filler, reading as though it was culled by speechwriters from recycled campaign rhetoric. The only parts that the reader can reliably infer were written by the candidate herself are the barbs of vitriol scattered throughout denouncing political allies and enemies alike.

Why, then, has Amazon intervened so aggressively to promote it? While commercial aims cannot be ruled out, Amazon’s concerns are primarily political, and its removal of the critical comments constitute an act of political censorship.

Clinton’s book is a manifesto for the growing drive by major corporations, working with the intelligence agencies and governments, to censor free speech on the Internet.

It provides the most comprehensive account to date of the narrative that Donald Trump’s victory was the result of a nefarious “Russian plot to sabotage my campaign and help elect Trump,” which she referred to as “the political equivalent of 9/11”.

This “attack” took the form of the propagation of “fake news”, which is a term bestowed by Clinton upon any fact that she deems embarrassing to her campaign. To prevent the propagation of such “fake news”, corporations must be empowered to block it.

She writes, “Much of what we see online is governed by a series of algorithms that determine what content appears in our Facebook and Twitter feeds, Google search results, and so on. One factor for these algorithms is popularity. If lots of users share the same post or click on the same link—and if key ‘influencers’ with large personal networks do as well—then it’s more likely to pop up on your screen.”

She adds, “Companies such as Facebook, Twitter, and Google have already begun taking steps—adjusting algorithms, deactivating bot networks, and partnering with fact-checkers—but they must do more.”

Those particularly susceptible to “fake news”, she writes, are those who opposed her on the left. “The Russians made a particular effort to target voters who had supported Bernie Sanders in the primaries,” Clinton writes, “including by planting fake news on pro-Sanders message boards and Facebook groups and amplifying attacks by so-called Bernie Bros.”

Clinton warns, ominously, “This can all happen again if we don’t stop it,” urging politicians to push harder on the “Russia investigation”.

Since the election, Facebook and Google (whose former CEO she praises as a key ally of her campaign) have both published documents stating their intent to crack down on “fake news”. Google has demonstratively acted on these intentions, slashing the traffic of left-wing, progressive, and anti-war websites, including the WSWS, whose traffic from the search engine has fallen by two-thirds.

Clinton’s book, aside from constituting a bitter and subjective rant, is a key component in the drive to censor free speech on the Internet. It has been carefully choreographed with statements by the intelligence agencies, high-ranking members of Congress such as Democratic Senator Mark Warner, the ranking member of the Senate Intelligence Committee, and “investigations” by the New York Times and Washington Post.

This is why Amazon, a giant monopoly that fears growing discontent among its own highly-exploited workforce as much as it does the broader disaffection with the right-wing politics of the Democratic Party, is censoring criticism of Clinton’s book.

YOU’RE NOT THE ONLY ONE AMAZON THOUGHT WAS PREGNANT A lot of folks got notifications about their “baby registry.” [HuffPost]

This review of Hillary Clinton’s book, which just set a sales record, talks about its “absence of Hillary Clinton,” and it’s worth a read.

22 thoughts on “ censors criticism of Hillary Clinton’s book

  1. The People’s Email Network, PO Box 35022, L.A., CA 90035

    During the last election campaign a considerable number of people
    emailed us incessantly, telling us how much they hated Bernie
    Sanders, and how he should go straight to hell, even after Clinton
    had secured the Democratic nomination.

    And we would respond to their deaf ears that they were literally
    dooming the chances of their own chosen candidate, by going out of
    their way to alienate their best potential policy allies, and
    spitefully and gratuitously so.

    Bernie of course campaigned hard for Hillary. He did what he could.

    But you would never know it from her tell nothing book, blaming him
    for gently pointing out her conspicuous flaws as a candidate, as if
    nobody would have otherwise noticed. As if Trump would never have
    attacked her character if Bernie had not politely asked if we could
    see her Wall Street speeches.

    How quickly she has forgotten her own applause for Bernie when he
    declared “enough of the damn emails.” Trump himself called Bernie
    stupid in the moment for taking that off the table in the Democratic

    “I was on my way to winning before . . . ” now claims Hillary,
    blaming everybody but herself. Correction, at best Hillary was on her
    way to a nail biter, just as we sadly predicted.

    And why was that? How about the worst corporate VP pick possible,
    when either Bernie as a running mate, which we were pushing for once
    she won the nomination, or even Elizabeth Warren, would have swept
    her into the White House in landslide? Wanna know how much Kaine
    helped the ticket? On election night even his home state of VA was in

    How about her refusal to take a position on the TPP, about the most
    unpopular proposal out there, in her platform? And those are just
    some of the things she could have done differently during the
    campaign itself, leaving all past baggage aside.

    Based on her own campaign decisions, Hillary was at best on her way
    to an interminable crucifixion at the hands of a Congress STILL
    controlled by the Republicans. It was not just Trump chanting “lock
    her up,” this was the entire right wing echo chamber, and it had been
    going on nonstop for decades.

    Hillary was on her way to winning until Hillary happened.

    Was Comey NOT supposed to investigate questionable stuff. That was
    the complain Trump had himself against Comey as the reason for firing

    The irony is that it is now Trump who is being crucified, and boy
    howdy to that, at the hands of Robert Mueller and his nightmare team
    of seasoned prosecutors.

    “I guess people just don’t like me,” now says Clinton, as if it’s all
    their fault, not hers. Lucky she was running against someone ever
    MORE disliked than herself. And she STILL could not win. Being hated
    by more people than anyone else sure didn’t stop him, did it now?

    “It was the sexism and the misogyny,” laments Clinton. Oh, really?
    How is it then that Hillary lost the vote of white women in this
    election? Are women the “bros” now too??

    Russia spent what, $100,000 on facebook? How was a billion dollars in
    corporate Hillary campaign money chest supposed to compete with that?

    So where does this all leave us?

    The real lesson to be learned from this campaign is that Democrats
    lose by running as Republicans. And the person pointing the way to
    path of victory REMAINS Bernie Sanders.

    This week Bernie introduced a systematic plan to transition to a full
    single payer system. There is a compelling majority of the American
    people available to rally behind this program, to put the . . . wait
    for it . . . DEMOCRATS back in political power, on this one issue
    alone. All the other potential presidential candidates have signed on
    as co-sponsors, because they recognize that this is the wave of the

    But Bernie himself is providing the leadership we so desperately need
    most of all. That is why we continue to stand with Bernie, and will
    forever. Get your own cap and stand with us.

    Bernie Forever caps:

    And please submit this action page for Medicare For All NOW if you
    have not done so already. And most importantly, use the social media
    buttons at the top of this page to share it with everyone else you
    know, and do that over and over as much as you can.

    Medicare For All NOW action page:


  2. Pingback: Hillary Clinton made Trump president, book review | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: London bomb abused for Internet censorship | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: boss resigns in sexual harassment scandal | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  5. Pingback: Labour party in the USA? | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  6. Pingback: United States Clintonites red-bait Donna Brazile as ‘Russia’s tool’ | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  7. Pingback: US Trump administration threatens Internet neutrality | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  8. Pingback: boss exploits, oppresses workers | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  9. Pingback: American Green party witch-hunted in ‘Russia’ hysteria | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  10. Pingback: Chelsea Manning’s United States Senate campaign and her opponents | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  11. Pingback:, tax dodgers | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  12. Pingback: Amazon, other corporations, selling nazi books | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  13. Pingback:, of world’s richest man, treats workers like shit | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  14. Pingback: I lost election, being a capitalist, Hillary Clinton admits | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  15. Pingback: Honduras dictatorship using British spyware | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  16. Pingback: YouTube favouritism for Murdoch, other corporate media | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  17. Pingback: Facebook censoring non-corporate media voices | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  18. Pingback: English taxpayers’ millions to exploiters | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  19. Pingback: British sexually abusive police spies and Lush cosmetics campaign | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  20. Pingback: Facebook censorship getting worse again | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  21. Amazon is censoring
    ‘Capitalism on a Ventilator:
    The Impact of Covid-19 in China & the U.S.’
    We need your help to distribute the book!

    Donate to oppose Amazon censorship and receive a free copy of ‘Capitalism on a Ventilator’

    Make a tax deductible $25 contribution to oppose Amazon censorship and receive a free copy of Capitalism on a Ventilator.

    ‘Capitalism on a Ventilator: The Impact of Covid-19 in China & the U.S.’ is a new anthology comparing the effective Chinese response to COVID-19 with the disastrous response in the U.S. It pushes back against the racist anti-China campaign in U.S. media. Amazon is currently censoring the distribution of this book. We need your support to distribute the book and fight back against censorship!

    Due to the growing hostility of the U.S. establishment toward China and the accompanying surge in anti-Asian racism, it was an enormous challenge to find printing and distribution for this anthology, which includes many published authors including Ajamu Baraka, Monica Moorehead, Mumia Abu Jamal, Margaret Kimberley, Vijay Prishad, Lee Siu Hin, Sara Flounders, Carlos Martinez, Kevin Zeese, Deirdre Griswold, Max Blumenthal and more.

    The effort to place this challenging book on a large corporate website turned into a several month struggle with the world’s largest online bookseller – Amazon. Amazon Books claims ease of placement, best order fulfillment and lack of censorship, but failed to deliver.

    Amazon’s block of this book is a clear example of U.S. corporate censorship. We were notified: “Due to the rapidly changing nature of information around coronavirus, we are referring customers to official sources for advice about the prevention or treatment of the virus. Amazon reserves the right to determine what content we offer according to our content guidelines. Your book does not comply with our guidelines. As a result, we are not offering your book for sale.”

    The book’s table of contents and list of authors, along with four chapters, is available at
    Readers are urged to break the ban on “Capitalism on a Ventilator” by sharing the link and your short reviews widely on social media. Maintain pressure against Amazon banning books with a left perspective by tweeting the Washington Post @JeffBezos.

    Although Amazon claims it publishes only “official sources for advice” on the COVID-19 virus, Amazon has allowed books promoting wild conspiracy theories that the virus is exaggerated, a hoax or human-made and masks and quarantines are useless. During the pandemic Amazon has also listed products that are dangerous quack “cures” for COVID-19.

    Hostility to China as national policy impacts every area of discussion. This is reflected in the trade war, sanctions and military operations, and by canceling educational and cultural exchanges and any attention or coverage on any level of China’s accomplishments. In retrospect, it is hardly surprising it extends to blocking books and topics of discussion.

    Many important chapters in this anthology were written in March, April, and May of 2020 as the full impact of the COVID-19 pandemic hit the U.S., and people were actively looking for answers and asking questions.

    The questions working people worldwide started asking sent U.S. media outlets and private corporate platforms into a wall of censorship and political repression. Why has China done so much better in containing COVID-19 and saving lives? The answer corporate media gave was an onslaught of racist and imperialist attacks against China including claims of dishonesty, brutality and suppression of information. Several major news sources even went so far as to accuse China of manufacturing the virus. Any evidence contrary to the corporate narrative was thoroughly suppressed.

    This book was written by people around the world and edited by a U.S. activist and a Chinese activist. The evidence and data available provide a very different answer from that given the corporate media. China contained the virus because their free medical care and planned economic system is science based and intensely cooperative. By every statistic, countries building socialism did far better in combating the virus — Cuba, China, Laos, Vietnam and North Korea, to name a few. We hope you read this book and explore the reasons why China and other countries building socialism did far better than the capitalist world did.

    Donate to oppose Amazon censorship and receive a free copy of ‘Capitalism on a Ventilator’


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.