Democracy and non-democracy in North Africa and Europe

This video is called Outsourcing Torture. It is about NATO countries co-operating with regimes like Mubarak’s in Egypt, in torturing prisoners from, eg, Guantanamo.

By Steve McGiffen in Britain:

Redefining democracy

Monday 04 June 2012

Egyptians have been taking to the streets this week in protest at the “farcical” trial of ex-despot Hosni Mubarak.

Mubarak was convicted of “complicity” in killing hundreds of protesters during the uprising that overthrew him last year, but cleared of having ordered the crackdown and of various corruption charges.

The trial is one of many ominous signs that Egypt’s “transition to democracy” is not going smoothly – the continued rule of the generals and controversial decisions by the election commission on who was allowed to stand in the recent elections are other examples.

To listen to most mainstream commentators and politicians, you would think that democracy was an absolutely uncontested concept, a word we can all easily and accurately define.

That countries are democratic, or they aren’t.

The member states of the European Union, like the United States, are “democracies” and the EU has an unquestioned commitment to democracy and its development around the world.

It says so in the Treaty of Lisbon, the latest version of the EU’s fundamental law, and in the Copenhagen Criteria, which applicant countries must meet if they are to be accepted into the club.

The failure on the part of the EU and its member states to make any effort whatsoever to dislodge the Mubarak dictatorship, or that of Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali in Tunisia, despite being the biggest export market for both regimes and therefore potentially influential, rather tarnished this democratic image.

The French foreign minister’s offer to send riot police to help Ben Ali stay in power and Tony Blair‘s description of Mubarak as “immensely courageous and a force for good” were just two incidents in Europe’s own “transition” – from supporting the dictators to reluctantly accepting the new situation.

This has not eroded Europe’s view of itself as a democratic bloc, but it will certainly have increased scepticism about that self image among the peoples of north Africa, whose memories of colonialism are still fresh.

The dominant assumption in Europe is still that if the “Arab Spring” is successful its end product will be political systems modelled on our own.

The relationship between “democratic” Europe and “transitioning” north Africa is one of teacher-student – and teacher-student of a distinctly old-fashioned stripe in which knowledge passes only in one direction.

And the talking heads warn that grave dangers will arise if the student fails the course.

The dictatorships were, in the view of European elites, able to guarantee decades of “stability.”

They were also seen as allies in the “war on terror.”

Stability is the real aim of EU external policies – defined as a condition conducive to European corporate profits.

2 thoughts on “Democracy and non-democracy in North Africa and Europe

  1. Egypt: Pro-revolution forces nearly scored half of the votes but were cut out from the presidential run off

    If the elections of May 23/24 would have been for a proportional parliament the pro-Tahrir forces with some 40% of the electorate behind them had emerged as the strongest force. Actually that is a big step ahead compared to the parliamentary elections of last autumn. The run off will be, nevertheless, between the two other players of the power triangle: namely the old regime backed by the army and the Muslim Brotherhood (MB). The Tahrir will have to rely on taking to the street. The recent acquittal of Mubarak sons and police generals poor fresh fuel into the fire. Huge popular mobilisations are possible.


  2. Ex-president found guilty in absentia

    TUNISIA: A military court has convicted the former president in absentia of inciting violence and sentenced him to 20 years in prison.

    Former president Zine El Abidine Ben Ali was overthrown in a month-long popular uprising last year and fled to Saudi Arabia on January 14, 2011.

    Mr Ben Ali’s conviction was for an incident the day after he left when security forces opened fire on protesters in the central town of Ouardanine, killing four.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.