Sister Mary MacKillop, from excommunication to sainthood

Mary WardFrom an earlier posting at this blog:

In 1631, an exhausted 46-year-old woman arrived at the gates of the Vatican. Mary Ward, a Yorkshire-born nun, had walked more than 1,500 miles from her order in present-day Belgium to Rome, knowing that she might end up in prison.

For more than two decades, she had been leading an order of devotees that lived in defiance of the Vatican’s strict rules that confined nuns to their cloisters.

Ward had taught her religious sisters not to wear habits and trained them to work with the poor and the persecuted, and to found and teach in Catholic schools. She also encouraged women to perform in plays, a move considered scandalous in Shakespearean times when all female roles were played by boys.

She was living at the height of the Roman Inquisition where accusations of heresy abounded. The pope at the time was Urban VIII, the same pontiff who threw Galileo in prison for daring to suggest that the Earth orbited around the Sun.

Now this revolutionary woman had gone to Rome asking him for official approval of her rebellious order which lived in defiance of centuries of Catholic teaching.

It was, therefore, perhaps of little surprise that Urban threw Ward in jail and issued a papal bull ordering her movement to be suppressed.

But now the same institution that declared her a “heretic” has taken the first decisive step towards making Ward a saint.

It took the Roman Catholic church nearly four centuries to at least implicitly admit their mistake in persecuting Sister Mary Ward. Feelings of satisfaction about this change, however, should be mixed with criticism of how the Vatican uses ex-“heretics” as propaganda props.

Three centuries after Mary Ward, there was another Sister Mary. Not in Europe, but in Australia: Mary MacKillop. She seems to have had much in common with the elder Mary: her concerns for poor people and education. And her persecution by church authorities.

Sister Mary MacKillop (1842-1909), Australian nun, foundress of the congregation of Sisters of St Joseph of the Sacred Heart. Photo credit: Wikipedia

Sister Mary MacKillop (1842-1909), Australian nun, foundress of the congregation of Sisters of St Joseph of the Sacred Heart (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

From the Australian Broadcasting Corporation:

Mary Mackillop exposed child sex abuse

Lindy Kerin reported this story on Saturday, September 25, 2010 08:09:00

ELIZABETH JACKSON: Just weeks away from her canonisation, an ABC documentary will reveal the true story behind the excommunication of Mary MacKillop. The Australian nun was excommunicated from the Catholic Church in 1871.

But an ABC television documentary on the life of Mary MacKillop says she was excommunicated after her order of nuns reported child sexual abuse at a parish north of Adelaide. …

LINDY KERIN: The Compass documentary called Mary Miracles and Saints looks back at the life and times of Mary MacKillop. At 25 she became the first Sister of St Joseph and the leader of the new order.

Josephite Sister Marie Foale says at the time it was a controversial move.

MARIE FOALE: Mary and the Sisters were a great threat to these bishops; they were Australian, they were independent thinkers, they went out among the people. They worked among the poor; they didn’t care about the rich. So they just didn’t know how to handle them.

LINDY KERIN: But it was when the Sisters of St Joseph uncovered and reported the sexual abuse of children by one of the local priests at Kapunda that lead to a dramatic chain of events. They alleged that Father Patrick Keating was abusing school children. Strong disciplinary action was taken by the church’s vicar-general. Father Gardiner says some members of the clergy wanted revenge.

PAUL GARDINER: Priests being annoyed that somebody had uncovered it – that would probably be the way of describing it – and being so angry that the destruction of the Josephites was decided on.

LINDY KERIN: In 1871, when she was 29, Mary MacKillop was excommunicated from the church. It was portrayed in the 1994 film Mary.

(Excerpt from film Mary)

ACTOR: I Bishop Sheil through the power invested in me by the Holy Church of Rome do solemnly declare that you Sister Mary MacKillop are from this time forth excommunicated from the Holy Catholic Church.

Sister Mary MacKillop has one more thing in common with Sister Mary Ward. Now that she has been dead, safely dead for the “Holy Church of Rome”, unable to speak up for herself, for a long time, the “Holy Church of Rome” is using her as a propaganda prop.

By James Cogan:

Pope creates Australia’s first “saint”

26 October 2010

On October 17, in an elaborate ceremony in the Vatican, the Catholic nun and teacher Mary MacKillop was canonised by Pope Benedict XVI as the first Australian-born saint, more than a century after her death in 1909. The event was the end-product of an effort to utilise the canonisation campaign as a means of rehabilitating the badly battered standing of the Catholic Church in Australia.

MacKillop’s canonisation was heavily promoted in the preceding weeks by the Church and the entire political and media establishment. A television mini-series capped endless reviews of selective details of her life, accompanied by paeans to her miracle-making and healing capacities. In the hours before her elevation to sainthood, a light show beamed her image onto 13 pylons of the Sydney Harbour Bridge. The full Vatican service was televised live on state-owned and commercial cable television, complete with images of Australia’s foreign minister and former prime minister, Kevin Rudd, and his opposition counterpart, Julie Bishop, joining other “pilgrims” in St Peter’s Square, and obsequious commentary on the various feudalistic rituals associated with the event.

Politicians and editorialists lauded MacKillop as a “fair dinkum Aussie saint”. Labor Party Prime Minister Julia Gillard, a declared atheist, enthused: “This is a saint who rides horse-back for days under the searing Australian sun… who has grit under her fingernails and sweat on her brow.” Opposition leader Tony Abbott declared MacKillop “more than just a great Catholic, she was also a great Australian”. Some of the 8,000 Australians at the Vatican, unable to contain their enthusiasm, defied convention and broke into the nationalist sporting chant, “Aussie, Aussie, Aussie, Oi! Oi! Oi!”, when the Pope mentioned her name.

The reality of MacKillop’s life is a somewhat tragic story of a thoughtful and compassionate woman whose hopes were thwarted by that bastion of political and social reaction, the Catholic Church. Born to Scottish Catholic migrants in the working class suburbs of Melbourne in 1842, she grew up in difficult circumstances. She appears to have drawn from her own experiences, and those around her, a genuine desire to combat inequality and ignorance. Before there was any system of universal public education, she set out to convince the Church that it should set up schools that would accept students regardless of whether their parents could pay.

To achieve these ends, MacKillop helped found in 1867 an order of teaching nuns, the Sisters of Saint Joseph, or Josephites, who were required to take vows of poverty, no personal possessions and a willingness to travel anywhere to provide education services to the poor.

This was not, however, what the Church had in mind. The Josephites quickly came under attack for being insufficiently devout and for begging for food and money. After a series of conflicts with the Church, MacKillop was temporarily excommunicated in 1871, and the order’s vow of poverty repudiated, on Rome’s orders, in 1873.

MacKillop was ultimately removed in 1883 as head of the order over false accusations that she had become an alcoholic. By the time she regained the leadership 16 years later, in 1899, the Josephites had been transformed into a mainstay of the Australian Catholic establishment. When she died in 1909, the order was part of the sectarian, fee-charging Catholic school system, operating in opposition to the secular and free public school system that had by been established as a result of the struggles of the working class.

After being largely dismissed as a saint candidate for decades, calls within the Church for MacKillop’s canonisation gained momentum in the 1970s. She was ultimately beatified in 1995 by Pope John Paul II after a Church investigation decided that a woman’s recovery from leukaemia in 1961 was the miraculous outcome of her prayers to the long-dead nun. Soon after, the recovery, in 1993, of a woman diagnosed with lung and brain cancer, was also attributed to MacKillop, giving her the necessary two “miracles” to qualify for sainthood.

It was not simply the Catholic Church that latched on to MacKillop but a long line of media hacks, politicians and celebrities all queued up to exploit her canonisation as a convenient diversion from the increasingly harsh realities of everyday life and a means of promoting nationalism, backwardness and religious superstition.

The saturation media coverage of the event and MacKillop’s “miracles” drove issues such as the criminal war in Afghanistan, the catastrophic floods in Pakistan, the deepening global economic crisis and signs of escalating social tensions off the front pages and out of news broadcasts.

The same politicians hypocritically lauding MacKillop’s “compassion for the poor” were precisely those responsible for implementing the savage pro-market measures that have created today’s unprecedented gulf between rich and poor. A recent Salvation Army report found that more than two million Australians now live below the poverty line, struggling to survive from one day to the next. And the same media that praised MacKillop for fighting to provide the poor with equal access to education were those demanding that governments encourage private fee paying schools at the expense of public schools in working class areas.

Particularly pernicious has been the promotion of false hopes in miracles. In the area of health, medical science has made astonishing advances during the past decades, achieving cures that truly would have been miraculous 50, let alone 100 years ago. Yet today, there is a two-class health system, where the wealthy have access to the most up-to-date technology, while the majority face a rapidly deteriorating public health system starved of funds and increasingly incapable of providing timely, high quality treatment.

So prominent and dangerous have been the “medical miracle” claims that a number of medical specialists have felt obligated to publicly challenge them. Sydney oncologist David Bell, for example, who has written about the rare but established phenomenon of spontaneous cancer remission, told the Australian: “I’m very concerned that a lot of people will mistakenly think, ‘I just have to go down to Mary MacKillop’s grave and pray, and I’ll be cured’, and come away disappointed.”

For its part, the Church hierarchy is desperate to stem the decline in its following. Only 15 percent of the reputed five million nominal Catholics in Australia attend Sunday mass on an average weekend. Reactionary church teachings on homosexuality, contraception, sex-outside-marriage, abortion and in-vitro fertilisation are openly ignored and viewed with hostility or outright contempt.

After decades of stagnant recruitment into the priesthood, the average age of an Australian priest is now 60. Once figures of respect, priests are now overwhelmingly viewed with suspicion. An avalanche of child sex abuse scandals has rocked the Church over the past two decades, leaving few parents comfortable leaving their children alone with a member of the Catholic clergy.

Internationally the Church has latched on to saints and miracles as one means of clawing back support. From 1978 until his death in 2005, John Paul II created a staggering 482 saints, more than those created by his 17 predecessors put together. Not only that. He also beatified and prepared the way for the canonisation of hundreds more, including MacKillop.

Now formally anointed “Saint Mary of the Cross MacKillop” the Australian nun has been proposed, in a staggering act of cynicism, as a patron saint for sexually abused children by America, a Catholic publication in the US. “Like all saints she is a model for all Catholics”, an editorial declared, “but at this time abuse victims and their families need all the help they can get from heaven as on earth.”

In a time of immense and growing social distress, MacKillop’s alleged miraculous powers will undoubtedly be invoked as a reason to stay within the Catholic fold. One suspects that the impact will be minimal however. Facing vast economic and social shocks, masses of workers and youth in Australia and internationally will not be relying on divine intervention, but seeking a political means to defend their living standards and rights.


7 thoughts on “Sister Mary MacKillop, from excommunication to sainthood

  1. Pingback: Australian clerical child abuse | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  2. Pingback: Ancient Roman women priests-controversy catacomb on the Internet | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: Philosopher Baruch de Spinoza’s birthday today | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: Continue covering up child abuse, Australian bishops say | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  5. Pingback: Priests’, bishops’ sexual abuse of nuns | Dear Kitty. Some blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.