Professor leaves Catholic church because of anti-Semitism

Professor Wils

From Dutch NOS TV:

01 February 2009

Ethics professor Wils resigns from Roman Catholic church

The ethics professor at [Roman Catholic] Nijmegen university, Jean Pierre Wils, is resigning from the Roman Catholic church. He does not want to participate any longer in what he calls a totalitarian and anti-modern church.

To Wils, the rehabilitation by Pope Benedict of four reactionary bishops was the straw which broke the camel’s back. According to Wils, these four men, including the extremely controversial prelate Williamson, are deeply reactionary and anti-Semitic, and they support dictators.

Williamson is in denial on the mass murder of Jews, and says that there have never been any gas chambers in the nazi camps. Wils does not want to be in the same church with such a man.

4 thoughts on “Professor leaves Catholic church because of anti-Semitism

  1. I wish more Catholics were protesting.

    Comment by Jon — February 1, 2009 @ 5:01 pm

    Hi Jon, in fact more Catholics are protesting. The Dutch bishops have denounced the anti-Semitic views of Williamson. However, without criticizing the Vatican’s role in this, as far as I know. So, the criticism did not go far enough.

    Comment by Administrator — February 1, 2009 @ 5:08 pm

    Another traditionalist denies Shoah

    Ultra- Conservative priest disputes use of gas chambers

    (ANSA) – Treviso, January 29 – Another leading member of the traditionalist Catholic Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) has denied that gas chambers were used by the Nazis to exterminate Jews during the Second World War.

    ‘’I know that gas chambers existed as a means to disinfect, but I cannot say for sure if they killed anyone because I really haven’t looked into it,’’ Father Floriano Abrahamowicz, the head of SSPX in northeast Italy, told the Tribuna di Treviso daily on Thursday.

    The ultraconservative priest’s statements came a day after Israeli’s highest religious authority, the Chief Rabbinate, threatened to sever ties with the Vatican after Pope Benedict XVI lifted an excommunication on four SSPX bishops, including one who has repeatedly denied that the Shoah took place.

    The pope immediately responded by reiterating his strong stand against denying the Holocaust, saying that it was important to never forget the Shoah. This to appeared avert an official break, although the Rabbinate has yet to make a formal statement.

    The Rabbinate, as well as Jewish leaders in Italy and around the world, were particularly upset over the reinstatement of Bishop Richard Williamson. The British-born bishop recently told Swedish TV that he did not believe in the existence of gas chambers. In his view not six million but only 200,000 to 300,000 Jews died in Nazi concentration camps ‘’and not one of them in a gas chamber’’.

    The current SSPX head, Bishop Bernard Fellay, stated firmly that Williamson’s views did not reflect those of the order and he apologised to the pope for any problems his views may have created.

    He has also ordered Williamson not to voice his political opinions in public.

    However, according to Father Abrahamowicz, ‘’all this fuss over Msgr Williamson’s statements is being exploited against the Vatican. Williamson simply expressed his doubts. He did not deny the Holocaust, as the press has mistakenly said he did; he only gave a technical opinion on the gas chambers’’.

    ‘’The question of denying the Holocaust is a false problem because it focuses on numbers and methods and does not address the real problem,’’ he added.

    ‘’Had Msgr. Williamson denied on TV the (1915) genocide of 1.2 million Armenians by the Turks I don’t think the press would have acted the same way ,’’ Father Abrahamowicz said.

    The Vatican has yet to reply to the ultra-conservative priest, but when Milan Archbishop Dionigi Tettamanzi was asked for his view he observed that ‘’the Holy Father has been clear and explicit’’ on the church’s relations with both the SSPX and Jews.

    Lifting the excommunication on the four bishops, he added, ‘’was an act of mercy which in no way represented a compromise,’’ he said.

    In order to truly return to the fold, the archbishop added, they must renew ‘’their loyalty to the Church and its teachings,’’ including the changes made by the Second Vatican Council in the early 1960s.

    The archbishop of Treviso, Msgr, Andrea Bruno Mazzoccato, adopted a similar position and told the members of his diocese that any stance on the Holocaust which differed from the one expressed by the pope ‘’has no foundation and is unconnected to Christian thought and an elementary sense of humanity’’.

    He then repeated the pope’s warning to be on guard against ‘’the unexpected power which evil can exert on the hearts of man’’.

    The SSPX was created in 1970 by late dissident French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre who broke with Rome over the changes made at the Vatican Council.

    Among the changes the group opposed was the decision to celebrate Mass in local languages rather than in Latin and to adopt the view that Jews today should not be blamed for the death of Christ. Lefebvre, who died in 1991, was excommunicated in 1998 for ordaining four bishops, including Williamson, in defiance of a direct order from John Paul II. The four bishops were also excommunicated.

    Abrahamowicz’s views have come under heavy fire from the governor of the Veneto region, where the headquarters of his SSPX branch is located.

    ‘’I don’t know if we’re dealing with plain ignorance, madness or some horrifying political choice, but if any priest denies the Holocaust, denies the existence of gas chambers, then he’d best change jobs,’’ said Giancarlo Galan, of the center-right People of Freedom party, ‘’And if any of these priests happen to live in the Veneto region, as is the case with Father Abrahamowicz, then they’d best move out and, who knows, even take refuge in one of those concentration camps they know so much about,’’ he added.

    Comment by Administrator — February 1, 2009 @ 6:57 pm

    For anyone to leave the Church because of the twisted views of one individual does not make sense. The Catholic Church holds no Anti-Semitic views. The individual in question, at the time of the remarks, was not even a member of the Catholic Church, but a break away society called ‘The Society of Pius X.’

    The recent move by the Pope to bring this society back into full communion with the Church was an attempt to bring unity and had nothing to do with the remarks of Bishop Williamson.

    One cannot judge the Church as a whole based on some of it’s members. Look at what the Church teaches, not what one particular member has to say.

    Comment by Paolo — February 2, 2009 @ 3:00 pm

    Hi Paolo: “The individual in question, at the time of the remarks, was not even a member of the Catholic Church, but a break away society called ‘The Society of Pius X.’” Indeed. The Vatican might, and should, have taken Williamson’s expressed views into account before making the decision rehabilitating him. Rehabilitating, not just as an ordinary Roman Catholic; but as a priest and a bishop.

    By the way, the chair of the Dutch bishop’s conference today has not just condemned Williamson’s views, but the rehabilitation decision as well. I wonder what the Vatican will do with that criticism.

    Comment by Administrator — February 2, 2009 @ 4:43 pm


  2. Pingback: Nazis in the United States Republican party | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: Fascist anti-student threats in Quebec | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: United States girls’ religious baseball ban | Dear Kitty. Some blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.