In Guantanamo Bay, torture is legal, poetry is not

This video is called Close Guantanamo! Amnesty [International] Speaks Out.

From British daily The Independent:

Inmates’ words: The poems of Guantanamo

The publication of an anthology of works, composed on paper cups by detainees, provides a harrowing insight into the torments and fading hopes of prisoners. Leonard Doyle reports

Published: 21 June 2007

The words of the celebrated Pakistani poet were scratched on the sides of a Styrofoam cup with a pebble. Then, under the eyes of Guantanamo Bay‘s prison guards, they were secretly passed from cell to cell. When the guards discovered what was going on, they smashed the containers and threw them away, fearing that it was a way of passing coded messages.

Fragments of these “cup poems” survived, however, and are included in an 84-page anthology entitled Poems from Guantanamo: the Detainees Speak, to be published later this year by the University of Iowa Press.

The verses provide a harrowing insight into the torments and fading hopes of the prisoners. Only two Guantanamo inmates have been charged with a crime.

They were brought to light by Marc Falkoff, a US professor of law with a doctorate in American literature. He represents 17 Yemeni inmates and has made 10 visits to Guantanamo. He dedicates the book to “my friends inside the wire”.

In the summer of 2005 Professor Falkoff was sent two poems from his clients. Written in Arabic, they were included in letters they could legally send. Because all communication with the detainees is deemed a potential threat to national security, everything – letters, interview notes, legal documents – must be sealed and sent to a US intelligence facility for review. The two poems were deemed a potential risk and remain classified to this day.

Professor Falkoff contacted other lawyers and discovered that several had received poems from their clients. Other detainees, like the two released Britons, Moazzam Begg and Martin Mubanga, wrote poetry while in prison and brought them with them on their release.

Censorship remains absolute at the camp however. As far as the US military is concerned: “poetry … presents a special risk, and DoD [Department of Defence] standards are not to approve the release of any poetry in its original form or language”. The fear, officers say, is that allegorical imagery in poetry may be used to convey coded messages to militants outside.

That is scoffed at by Professor Falkoff. “These are the same military censors who in 2004 tried to stop me receiving allegations of abusive treatment of my clients who were being subjected to intense heat and cold and forced to remain standing.” He added: “If the inmates were writing words like ‘the Eagle flies at dawn‘, the censors might have a case, but they are not. I fully accept their right to stop any coded messages to militants outside. But what the military fears is not so much the possibility of secret messages being communicated, but the power of words to make people outside realise that these are human beings who have not had their day in court.”

The thoughts of the inmates are considered so potentially dangerous by the US military that they are not even trusted with pen and paper. The only exception is an occasional 10-minute period when they are allowed to write to their families via the International Red Cross. Even then the words they write are heavily censored.

The 380 or so inmates of Guantanamo include some avowed Islamic militants and al-Qa’ida fighters. But the majority are there because they were swept up by the police and intelligence services of other countries working on behalf of the US. In their despair many of these detainees have turned to verse to express their innermost feelings.

Others have attempted or committed suicide. One of the poets is a Bahraini man who has been held in solitary confinement since the end of 2003. He has tried to kill himself 12 times while in the prison. On one occasion, he was found by his lawyer, hanging by his neck and bleeding from a gash to his arm.

There are other tragic tales behind the verses. The “cup poems” of Guantanamo speak of the strange absence of flowers in spring, the bangles worn by young women and handcuffs on the militants.

Fragments survived in the memory of the poet Shaikh Abdurraheem Muslim Dost after his eventual release, but thousands of lines of poetry he wrote in prison have disappeared.

Dost, a respected religious scholar, poet, and journalist – and author of nearly 20 books – until his arrest in 2001, spent nearly three years in Guantanamo with his brother. Sent home two years ago, the brothers were picked up by Pakistani intelligence and they too disappeared. Nothing has been heard of them since.

Aami al Haj, a Sudanese national, was a journalist covering the war in Afghanistan for al-Jazeera television, when, in 2001, he was arrested stripped of his passport and press card and handed over to US forces. He was tortured at both Bagram air base and Kandahar before being transferred to Guantanamo Bay. The US military says he was a financial courier for Chechen rebels and that he assisted al-Qa’ida but has offered no evidence to support the claims.

Quite some politico bigwigs in the USA support Chechen nationalism out of Russophobia left over from the Cold War.

The US military does not have to fabricate any ‘evidence’ to prove that, as they say so openly themselves.

However, those people ‘of course’ don’t go to Guantanamo Bay, and continue to be powerful political insiders.

“When I heard pigeons cooing in the trees, Hot tears covered my face,” he wrote from his prison cell. “They have monuments to liberty And freedom of opinion, which is well and good. But I explained to them, that Architecture is not justice.”


Humiliated In The Shackles

By Sami al Hajj

When I heard pigeons cooing in the trees,

Hot tears covered my face.

When the lark chirped, my thoughts composed

A message for my son.

Mohammad, I am afflicted.

In my despair, I have no one but Allah for comfort.

The oppressors are playing with me,

As they move freely around the world.

They ask me to spy on my countrymen,

Claiming it would be a good deed.

They offer me money and land,

And freedom to go where I please.

Their temptations seize

My attention like lightning in the sky.

But their gift is an empty snake,

Carrying hypocrisy in its mouth like venom,

They have monuments to liberty

And freedom of opinion, which is well and good.

But I explained to them that

Architecture is not justice.

America, you ride on the backs of orphans,

And terrorize them daily.

Bush, beware.

The world recognizes an arrogant liar.

To Allah I direct my grievance and my tears.

I am homesick and oppressed.

Mohammad, do not forget me.

Support the cause of your father, a God-fearing man.

I was humiliated in the shackles.

How can I now compose verses? How can I now write?

After the shackles and the nights and the suffering and the tears,

How can I write poetry?

My soul is like a roiling sea, stirred by anguish,

Violent with passion.

I am a captive, but the crimes are my captors’.

I am overwhelmed with apprehension.

Lord, unite me with my son Mohammad.

Lord, grant success to the righteous.

An Al-Jazeera cameraman, Sami al Hajj, a Sudanese, was visiting his brother in Damascus after the 11 September attacks when he got a call asking him to go to Pakistan to cover the impending war in Afghanistan. Instead, he ended up in Guantanamo where he claims he has been severely and regularly beaten, scarring his face.

Death Poem

By Jumah al Dossari

Take my blood.

Take my death shroud and

The remnants of my body.

Take photographs of my corpse at the grave, lonely.

Send them to the world,

To the judges and

To the people of conscience,

Send them to the principled men and the fair-minded.

And let them bear the guilty burden, before the world,

Of this innocent soul.

Let them bear the burden, before their children and before history,

Of this wasted, sinless soul,

Of this soul which has suffered at the hands of the “protectors of peace”.

Arrested in Pakistan and held in solitary confinement since 2003, Jumah al Dossari’s mental wellbeing is worrying his lawyers. The 33-year old Bahraini national has tried to kill himself 12 times since his incarceration in Guantanamo. On one visit, his lawyer found him hanging in a bedsheet noose, with a deep gash in one wrist. In a letter Mr Dossari wrote in 2005, he said: “The purpose of Guantanamo is to destroy people and I have been destroyed.”

Is It True?

By Osama Abu Kadir

Is it true that the grass grows again after rain?

Is it true that the flowers will rise up again in the Spring?

Is it true that birds will migrate home again?

Is it true that the salmon swim back up their streams?

It is true. This is true. These are all miracles.

But is it true that one day we’ll leave Guantanamo Bay?

Is it true that one day we’ll go back to our homes?

I sail in my dreams. I am dreaming of home.

To be with my children, each one part of me;

To be with my wife and the ones that I love;

To be with my parents, my world’s tenderest hearts.

I dream to be home, to be free from this cage.

But do you hear me, oh Judge, do you hear me at all?

We are innocent, here, we’ve committed no crime.

Set me free, set us free, if anywhere still

Justice and compassion remain in this world!

Shortly after 11 September, Osama Abu Kadir travelled to Pakistan to perform charity work in Afghanistan with the Islamic missionary group Tablighi Jamat. The US claims Tablighi was providing fighters for jihad in Afghanistan and arrested Mr Kadir near Jalalabad in November 2001. In his native Jordan, he was known as a dedicated family man who worked as a truck driver. In Guantanamo, he is known as prisoner number 651.

See also here.

40 thoughts on “In Guantanamo Bay, torture is legal, poetry is not

  1. Redgraves Present Poems from Guantanamo at Culture Project Dec. 9

    By Adam Hetrick
    09 Dec 2007

    The Culture Project presents The Redgraves: Poems from Guantanamo – featuring Vanessa, Lynn, Corin and Jemma Redgrave – as part of its ongoing A Question of Impeachment series Dec. 9.

    At 7:30 PM the Redgraves take to the Culture Project stage to read from “Guantanamo: The Detainees Speak,” a collection of poems written by detainees held in the U.S. detention center at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. The collection’s editor, Marc Falkoff, is also slated to take part in the discussion and reading. The evening is presented in partnership with the Center for Constitutional Rights.

    As previously reported by, the Culture Project and filmmakers Emily Kunstler and Sarah Kunstler of Off Center Media, have begun documenting the discussions due to nationwide and international demand. The internet broadcasts will be made available shortly following the live events at

    A Question of Impeachment, which debates the impeachment of U.S. President George W. Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney, continues Sundays and Mondays through Dec. 16. Sunday discussions approach the issues as presented through film, theatre, music and other art forms, while the Monday counterparts are focused on the articles of impeachment directly, through depositions modeled on actual impeachment hearings.

    Among the individuals previously named to take part in A Question of Impeachment’s Sunday series are Kathleen Chalfant, Phoebe Snow, Annabella Sciorra, Kristen Johnston, Tom Cavanagh, Khaliah Ali, Bobby Cannavale, Staceyann Chin, Willie Garson, Julie Goldman, Adam Rapp, Denis O’Hare, Scott Cohen playwright Sam Shepard, American poet Jorie Graham, New York-based band Mary Lee’s Corvette, performer and playwright Rinde Eckert and journalist Laura Flanders.

    The individuals taking part in the Monday night Questions include Michael Ratner, President of the Center for Constitutional Rights; Bruce Fein, Associate Deputy Attorney General under President Ronald Reagan and member of the American Bar Association’s Task Force on Presidential Signing Statements; and retired Colonel Ann Wright, one of three U.S. State Department officials who resigned in protest prior to the invasion and occupation of Iraq in March 2003. “Democracy Now!” host Amy Goodman is the newest addition to the Dec. 10 line-up.

    Also scheduled are best-selling political journalist and contributor Joe Conason; best-selling author of “The End of America,” Naomi Wolf; attorney Martin Garbus; attorney Elizabeth Holtzman; David Swanson, co-founder of; retired CIA officer Ray McGovern; former NBC correspondent Richard Valeriani; and journalist Scott Horton.

    Spring Awakening’s Steven Sater and Duncan Sheik will perform new songs as part of the Dec. 16 closing event.

    The topics scheduled include Initiation and Continuation of Illegal War, Torture and Extraordinary Rendition, Criminal Negligence and Hurricane Katrina, Warrantless Surveillance and Executive Power – Signing Statements and Suspension of Habeas Corpus.

    Tickets and detailed performance schedules are available by calling (212) 352-3101 or by visiting


  2. Pingback: Bagram, Worse Than Guantanamo? | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  3. Pingback: Unindicted prisoners in Bagram, Afghanistan | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  4. Pingback: 1,000th U.S. soldier dies in Afghanistan | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  5. Pingback: Civilian deaths in Afghanistan | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  6. Pingback: Bagram torture of Afghans continuing | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  7. Pingback: Investigate Bush’s war crimes, Canadian lawyers say | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  8. Pingback: Dutch parliament says close Bagram torture prison | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  9. Pingback: Red Cross against Bush’s torture | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  10. Pingback: Music torture by Bush regime | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  11. Pingback: Guantanamo and other US torture prisons | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  12. Pingback: USA: Relatives of September 11 victims condemn Guantánamo show trial | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  13. Pingback: Clash between US and Dutch lawmakers on Guantanamo Bay torture camp | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  14. Pingback: Innocent prisoners at Guantánamo torture camp | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  15. Pingback: Ex Bush supporter Andrew Sullivan compares Bush to Hitler because of torture | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  16. Pingback: British Conservative says Bush, stay out of Europe | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  17. Pingback: Afghan dies in Guantánamo torture camp | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  18. Pingback: Guantánamo, why is it still open? | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  19. Pingback: Bush administration medical experiments on detainees? | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  20. Pingback: Kafka’s Penal Colony on stage | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  21. Pingback: United States, British, rendition and torture | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  22. Pingback: Michael Moore’s film Sicko, on health care in the USA and elsewhere | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  23. Pingback: US psychologists vote against Guantanamo torture | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  24. Pingback: Guantanamo prisoners tortured, US Army judge admits | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  25. Pingback: New scandal in Guantanamo torture camp | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  26. Pingback: British, US, government torture | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  27. Pingback: New book on Guantanamo torture camp | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  28. Pingback: Demonstrations against Guantanamo Bay | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  29. Pingback: US torture prison Bagram in Afghanistan now twice the size of Guantanamo | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  30. Pingback: Bush’s Guantanamo soldiers vandalise Wikipedia | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  31. Pingback: Guantanamo operating manual posted on Internet | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  32. Pingback: Albanians sue on CIA torture flights | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  33. Pingback: Guantanamo Bay torture, stop cover up | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  34. Pingback: UK: ‘war against terrorism’ becomes war against Metallica rock | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  35. Pingback: US psychologist returns award in protest against Guantanamo torture | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  36. Pingback: Guantanamo torture camp still open today | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  37. Pingback: Musharraf dictatorship sends Pakistanis to secret prisons for US taxpayers’ dollars | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  38. Pingback: Massive anti-Trump demonstrations in Britain | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  39. Pingback: Journalist John Pilger organises film festival | Dear Kitty. Some blog

  40. Pingback: US columnist Thomas Friedman, warmonger and hypocrite | Dear Kitty. Some blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.